Different Batters Views / Batting Inputs Must Not Be Allowed In Ranked Games
-
@Squid_Adams_MLBTS . Let's put it like this you can't force someone to use a certain hitting view or hitting
-
@GoozeFn_PSN Should have never happened. That's when I stopped supporting the MLB. That World Series should be considered null/void and anyone responsible for taking part should be banned from baseball until they die (think Pete Rose) Rob Manfred is one of the worst things to happen to the sport. When something is wrong, I call it out.
-
@dap1234567890_PSN Elaborate on your hypothesis and how I fit each of the 13 cognitive distortions, please. Love that you're trying to make a higher IQ comment, but it just reads as "My community college professor recently told me about this."
-
@theBlindRhino_NSW I was leaning towards selling, but maybe your solution is more rational? Though I imagine, after any kind of break, I'll return to the same broken game I left. I took 4 years off this series hoping for improvements and it only seems to have gotten worse. I guess I should blame the enablers, most of which are in this thread.
-
@sbchamps17_NSW Very true. But I will campaign for SDS to do that. It would go a very long way to making this game consistently playable... and we all know that's true (even if it's tough for many to admit)
-
I think you should sell. Play single player games.
-
@theBlindRhino_NSW Basically what I did in those 4 years I took off lol. But video games are largely a social medium. Sure you can stick to Solitaire all the time, but then you're robbing yourself of the fun you might have had if you played Poker. This game is not completely broken. It CAN be an incredibly fun game. But you have to go through a lot of BS to get to that fun. The adjustments they'd have to make would be so incredibly small, which is why it's so frustrating to see the game in this state.
No one answered my question... maybe because it proves I'm right? If there's no advantage to using Strikezone batter view... then why do people take the time to go to the settings and make that adjustment? Do they like bulges? Or does it give them an advantage?
PS... as a Switch gamer myself... you should not be allowed to play XB or PS players online. Your hardware is far inferior and likely leads to more inconsistencies with how the game performs.
-
@Squid_Adams_MLBTS You can turn off cross play. You can join a league where everyone agrees to play a certain way. To declare that all online play should be restricted to one view and type of play is asinine. Some people use certain methods due to disabilities. So essentially we should get rid of ramps because everyone should be able to walk up stairs. Braille should be outlawed.
I use Strikezone because I like to concentrate on what matters in hitting a video baseball. I use zone hitting because it feels more realistic. I get destroyed in online play sometimes. Sometimes I think I lose to people who are not as good as I am. Sometimes I get lucky.
This whole thread just comes off as extremely myopic. SDS is never going to bend to your will. Nor should they. You are the minority here.
-
I love the freedom to use the setting available to me and everyone you sound very dictatorial
-
@theBlindRhino_NSW I would love to join a league! But then I wouldn't be able to collect cards which is part of the fun. And I'd have to find 29 people who are willing / able to commit to the idea. So not exactly a solution. Didn't know turning off cross-play was an option. Will look to make that change.
Will help you out a little bit though. Asinine means "extremely foolish or stupid." If that's a word you truly believe applies to me, then you're the one who actually fits that definition. I'd accept "insensitive" since I'm not even considering players with disabilities as I believe they are the exception and not the rule... but that's also a lot deeper than the simple suggestion that no one has a leg up on anyone based on settings. Also, I'm sure you realized how dumb your comparison was as soon as you hit enter... but ramps don't give someone a competitive advantage lol (unless whoever walks through the door first gets the open position at a job interview hahaha.) And braille is a tool for used to read and write, so don't know how you lumped that into a ramp / stair analogy.
You don't need a closeup of bulges to concentrate on what matters. I do the exact same thing in default. It's for a competitive advantage, pure and simple. The latter half about you getting destroyed by an opponent, or getting lucky and doing the destroying is called "inconsistency." The game tries to justify its flaws with "that's real baseball," which is fine and all... but then why are 90% of runs in this game coming from homers? That's arcade baseball. We can't have a game that's part simulation and part arcade. Then no one will understand why they destroyed someone or got destroyed. It's all a [censored] shoot. If I want to play a game of chance, I'll go to Vegas.
This thread is necessary and needed to be said. True... they won't do it because they've let their game regress for close to a decade now... but I'm just saying what everyone else who has fallen out of love with this game is thinking. The majority of people on this thread are against me, sure. Most people who spend time on forums are there because they are interested in / enjoy the subject matter presented on the forum. I wish I was easily pleased with inferior products like many of you or simply pretend this game doesn't exist like many people who have given up on the franchise. Perhaps as I continue to grow and improve as a person, I will ultimately leave this game to rot with the people who want it to be as bad as it can be. But as it stands right now, I haven't been able to completely shake the love I once had for baseball... so I will fight for it. This game has all the potential in the world, but right now they're satisfied being Gary Sanchez.
-
@SpcGarza_PSN Punctuation please. I think I understand what you're trying to say... but without proper punctuation, I can't say for certain. Also, please don't dilute the definition of "dictatorial."
-
@theBlindRhino_NSW said in Different Batters Views / Batting Inputs Must Not Be Allowed In Ranked Games:
You are the minority here.
MLB The Show MetaCritic User Ratings by Year:
2018- 6.3/10
2019- 7.4/10
2020- 6.8/10
2021- 4.4/10
2022- 5.4/10
2023- 6.3/10
2024- 4.3/10
2025- 5.3/10Must be a very rigorous rating scale... cuz I could swear 5.3's and 4.4's were not a sign of a good game.
-
Just give up because your not going to win, people have every right to use the settings that THEY want. You do not and will never have the right to tell people what settings they can use
-
@sbchamps17_NSW I didn't expect this to result in change lol... however, I do encourage people to give credit where it's due. I'm right and there's nothing wrong with that. I see a lot of defensive people who would be very sad if such a change was made. But this just mirrors politics. You can be presented with the most convincing and well articulated point of view, and still die at the stake for the dumb things you want.
-
So let’s compare your temper tantrum over nonsense to a real world example since you seem to want to compare this to steroid use.
If we follow your rules in MLB, every player has to use the exact same bat, exact same cleats, exact same gear - meaning no one can use any protective gear since that would possibly give them an unfair advantage. Every batter would have to stand in the exact same position, in the exact same spot in the box, take the exact same swing, and bat from the same side as everyone else. Pitchers would only be able to throw the exact same four pitches, throw with the same arm slot, the same velocity, and use the same windup. Remember, you want no one to have a supposed advantage and it all comes down to who can win using the exact same setup.
If you haven’t realized at this point that there’s nuance to playing a game and every player has a comfort zone and does what works best for them with the rules that are available, then I think it may be time for you to leave society and live on a compound by yourself or join a cult that believes everything exactly the same as you.
People have different comfort levels of how they want to play the game. There is no bonus for picking a specific setting, if this were the case, every streamer would be showing the bonus setup and every plebe would follow suit since they can’t think for themselves.
Get a grip and relax, or go start a cult. Either way, I’ll play how I want to play as long as SDS gives me those options.
-
@sbchamps17_NSW You have 3.8k posts!? Wow hahahahahaha.... of course you're against me coming after your fat, ugly girlfriend.
-
FYI some people that play this game have medical conditions like eye problems hence why they use Strikezone and timing or directional hitting. SDS taking that away will lose alot of people who play this game
-
@Squid_Adams_MLBTS Sir yes sir comrade I forgot I was in a school environment So sorry commander
-
First contribution to the forum; immediately jumps to the top of the trolls leaderboard.
-
@Squid_Adams_MLBTS said in Different Batters Views / Batting Inputs Must Not Be Allowed In Ranked Games:
Simple as that. Anytime I play someone who is using Strikezone or one of the zoomed in views, miraculously my ERA bloats from the high 2's to the low 6's. I could talk all day about this game having excessive home runs, too many random things happening outside of a player's control and every other flaw that drags it down, tarnishing their once sterling reputation... but I think much of that could be absolved if everyone had to play the game on an even playing field. No Strikezone, no timed or directional swinging... everyone plays the exact same way. No one uses Strikezone because it is visually pleasing. It's to get an unfair leg up on the competition and that's it. Ridiculous that this is allowed. It really ruins the experience.
I had a stroke. I am 50% legally blind in my right eye and only have 20% function in my right hand/arm.
Therefore, I need to use Directional as my hitting preference and Strike Zone as my viewing preference.
According to you; SDS shouldn't allow those options in H2H games.
You do know what that's called? If you don't; it's call Discrimination.
-
If the settings they're using are 'so superior'; then why don't you use them?
-
I guess your response to me may contain some derogatory remarks directed towards me. Since it seems that's how you reaping to people that don't agree with you
-
-
S SDS_JoeK_PSN locked this topic
