Controller issue

[HtonSecurity5x_PSN]

Hey all, bought a new controller for the start of the new game.
One issue I’m having is that anything in the bottom half of the zone, I continue to check swing at. It’s extremely annoying striking out looking on sweet pitches where I think I have good timing and I’m button mashing. Is this just a bad controller or something else?

[BobCarface_XBL]

I have the same issue

[Tylerslikewhoa_XBL]

What brand of controller is it?

[HtonSecurity5x_PSN]

@Tylerslikewhoa PlayStation