Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5
-
I know there are a few threads with this topic but I figure we use this one just for the Retro Finest guesses: personally I believe they will all be legends because the Finest are active players. However, I’m wrong….A LOT!
Yankees- Mickey Mantle
Orioles- Eddie Murray
Rays- Wade Boggs
Red Sox- Cy Young
Blue Jays- Tom HenkeGuardians- Bob Feller
White Sox- Frank Thomas
Tigers- Hal Newhouser
Twins- Joe Nathan
Royals- George BrettAstros- Jeff Bagwell
A’s- Vida Blue
Angels- Tim Salmon
Rangers- Pudge Rodriguez
Mariners- Mike CameronBraves- Warren Spahn
Mets- Mike Piazza
Marlins- AJ Burnett
Phillies- Jimmy Rollins
Nationals- Gary CarterCardinals- Lee Smith
Cubs- Fergie Jenkins
Pirates- Ralph Kiner
Reds- Joe Morgan
Brewers- Paul MolitorPadres- Trevor Hoffman
Giants- Christy Mathewson
Dodgers- Jackie Robinson
DBacks- Steve Finley
Rockies- Larry Walker -
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say quite a few Retro Finests from last year will be in this TA. Reuse as much pre-coded artwork as possible
-
I thought Christy Mathewson just got one in an Event? It is a 99
-
Rollins was the Phils TA4,won't be him.
probably Utley as Phils legends have recent cards cept him.
-
@TEXAS10PT you’re right, I have that one haha. Shows how much I’ve been paying attention this year.
-
@Ericulous1 said in Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5:
Cardinals- Lee Smith
Cubs- Fergie Jenkins
Pirates- Ralph Kiner
Reds- Joe Morgan
Brewers- Paul MolitorI'd vbe very disappointed with Lee Smith since we already have a 99 Helsley that is good for the rest of the year. But Smith does deserve a 99. My longshot hope is for a Matt Holliday. I'd take another 99 Musial as well.
-
@Ericulous1 said in Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5:
@TEXAS10PT you’re right, I have that one haha. Shows how much I’ve been paying attention this year.
So Mays gets the shaft again. 2013 99 Brandon Belts gets a retro finest. WTF Giants didn't win in 2013. Why do you hate Mays so much SDS?????
-
Pirates fans must be doing cartwheels over that Taillon RF
-
Tony Clark for the Tigers is a poor choice (Kaline doesn't have a 99 and is a team legend) but others got it worse - Kole Calhoun, Taillon, Zunino, Aparicio, Thome as a Twin. I'm sure there are others.
For the sake of people that will play '24 I hope there's a shake-up at SDS with who is making some of these decisions.
-
99 GEORGE BRETT
99 JIMMY ROLLINS
FINALLY!Some other nice cards in there as well. Napoli, Thome, Murray, Sheffield, Dunn, Billy Williams and Doby
-
@skywalker_25 said in Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5:
99 GEORGE BRETT
99 JIMMY ROLLINS
FINALLY!Some other nice cards in there as well. Napoli, Thome, Murray, Sheffield, Dunn, Billy Williams and Doby
Yeah. Rollins my replace my Core Jeter in my main lineup
-
@Dolenz_PSN - Holliday it is!!!
-
Michael Conforto for the Mets booooooo
-
Say what you will but I’m stocked for Zunino
Jason Bay as a Red Sox, over the Pirates is a slap in the face though. -
Trout is finest for Angels... And I thought nothing will disappoint me more than some of those "legends" retro finest. Yay Tony Clark for Tigers again. Who else was stupid as me thinking that Trout will not get another card and locked his chase card in collection? This is the only card that I hope they will actually make bad so I don't feel that stupid
edit: oh wrong thread, I wanted to post it to "cards revealed" thread, sorry guys
-
@MiKySaK said in Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5:
Trout is finest for Angels... And I thought nothing will disappoint me more than some of those "legends" retro finest. Yay Tony Clark for Tigers again. Who else was stupid as me thinking that Trout will not get another card and locked his chase card in collection? This is the only card that I hope they will actually make bad so I don't feel that stupid
That chase card is fire too. The new one can't be better, unless topped throughout. I was really hoping for one of the rookies. Neto, Schanual, Moniak, Joyce, and Detmers would have all been better choices. I really like Trout and Ohtani, but this game only uses them. It's like it's a two man team.
-
@X-FREEZE-OFF-X said in Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5:
@skywalker_25 said in Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5:
99 GEORGE BRETT
99 JIMMY ROLLINS
FINALLY!Some other nice cards in there as well. Napoli, Thome, Murray, Sheffield, Dunn, Billy Williams and Doby
Yeah. Rollins my replace my Core Jeter in my main lineup
I was thinking the same thing. Jeter is a Freak, but I always hit well with Rollins.
-
@MiKySaK said in Retro Finest Prediction thread TA5:
Trout is finest for Angels... And I thought nothing will disappoint me more than some of those "legends" retro finest. Yay Tony Clark for Tigers again. Who else was stupid as me thinking that Trout will not get another card and locked his chase card in collection? This is the only card that I hope they will actually make bad so I don't feel that stupid
edit: oh wrong thread, I wanted to post it to "cards revealed" thread, sorry guys
Where did you see Trout for the Angels Finest?
