Oldest Card
-
Josh Donaldson 88 I still use him every so often thinking about putting him back in one of my lineups I have him at P4
-
In terms of pitchers it is 93 Britton, in terms of bench it is 2nd half 92 Nelson Cruz, and in terms of my main lineup, it's 99 Austin Riley
-
I second 93 Britton and I have Takashi Babe on the bench.
-
I have had the 89 Sean Doolittle in my bullpen since whenever I first picked that card up. Still effective.
-
Brett for hitters, but thats probably too obvious of an answer lol. Joc is my main bench bat for events. I still use Britton on the pitching side. I switch guys around too much tbh
-
@eatyum_PSN said in Oldest Card:
In terms of pitchers it is 93 Britton, in terms of bench it is 2nd half 92 Nelson Cruz, and in terms of my main lineup, it's 99 Austin Riley
That second half Nelson Cruz is insane at P5, just has no fielding. I still had him in my lineup up until a couple weeks ago when my outfield just got too loaded.
-
Brett for hitting. He is just to good for me to take out. Bench guys I change up. After Brett it is probably Bill Hamilton that I use for lead off. Pitching it was 93 Britton but I was getting hit a lot for some reason so now it is 88 PS Grove. Delivery is good and I can paint with him.
-
For me its probably Topps Now Jhoan Duran, guy's still nasty and throws gas
-
Cover athlete collection Joe Mauer. Will be replaced by Finest Flashback
-
88 Lefty Grove
-
88 Monthly Reward Jordan Romano
-
Mauer's 96(?) card.
-
Yordan is the oldest one I still use occasionally
-
MA Berti, 96 Mauer, 93 Britton, and my CAP who I brought in for the Stolen Bases in the Judge program.
-
Pujols 700 MS card. Man is 42. Has to be one of the oldest in the game.
-
Aaron Judge live series
-
96 All Star Kenley Jansen from the NLW LS collection that was P5'd (99 overall) back in the early access days of the game (I was #16 to P5).
-
88 Joc Pederson and Chase Utley Prime off the bench as I am trying to P5 them and the same with FOTF Aroldis Chapman in the bullpen even though I have his 99 overall card.
-
@SchnauzerFace_MLBTS said in Oldest Card:
I have had the 89 Sean Doolittle in my bullpen since whenever I first picked that card up. Still effective.
I still have that Doolittle card in my pen too.
-
@CookieMonster64_NSW said in Oldest Card:
Just wondering, what is everyone's oldest card that they have that they still use in their main lineup, earlier, I played a guy on ranked seasons who had new-ish cards with some headliners and LOTF, etc.
But randomly off the bench, this guy brings out P5 Face of the Franchise Corey Seager, it felt really odd pitching against him again, and with the 99 Postseason one coming out I guess i'm gonna have to get used to it again.
P5 84 J Roll is still my lead off hitter.
