One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game
-
@mannyball21 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
I would put a Nomo rookie year card and a Strawberry prime in there.
Nomo would be so much fun to use. That delivery would be so unhittable.
-
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Nice list. Koufax and Strawberry are needed, though.
Great choices. The only reason Koufax and Strawberry aren’t on the list are so I could have Valenzuela and Gooden.
And that’s why you shouldn’t limit it to 1 per team
-
@PennyWiseLA25 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Nice list. Koufax and Strawberry are needed, though.
Great choices. The only reason Koufax and Strawberry aren’t on the list are so I could have Valenzuela and Gooden.
And that’s why you shouldn’t limit it to 1 per team
Meh, half the point of the list was to limit it to one player per team. Of course there are gonna be tough decisions and personal favorites over better players. It’s like the equivalent on a “desert island disc” list.
-
@formallyforearms said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Winfield was in 18, and unfortunately he wasnt very usable. His swing was terrible.
Lol I remember this. I’m was so excited to get Winfield’s card and was so disappointed I couldn’t hit a lick with him. In Winfield’s defense, no contact hitter could hit in 18. Would like to see how he would do in this years game. Plus Steinbrenner was an [censored] to him. That’s neither here nor there, but any chance I have to rip George Steinbrenner, I’ll take
-
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@formallyforearms said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Winfield was in 18, and unfortunately he wasnt very usable. His swing was terrible.
Lol I remember this. I’m was so excited to get Winfield’s card and was so disappointed I couldn’t hit a lick with him. In Winfield’s defense, no contact hitter could hit in 18. Would like to see how he would do in this years game. Plus Steinbrenner was an [censored] to him. That’s neither here nor there, but any chance I have to rip George Steinbrenner, I’ll take
Winfield hit over 450 HRs. He was a slugger. SDS didnt reflect it with that card. It's too bad.
-
All I want is Prince Fielder and A.Beltre.
-
@OceanBubbles000 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
All I want is Prince Fielder and A.Beltre.
Beltre was so tough to leave off the list. Spent years watching him own third base in Seattle. Honestly, I could’ve put either Fielder on the list. Prince and Cecil would be mashers. There would have to be a moment of Prince hitting one out of Tiger Stadium when he was a little kid. That was a playground legend in the early 90s!
-
92 Postseason Deion Sanders
-
Pedro Martinez.
-
Dodgers Steve Sax is all I could ever ask for....No one would use him but me, but it would be the dream.
I lie, for pitching I would love Pedro, Fernando, or Koufax.
-
@OreoRockstar said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Dodgers Steve Sax is all I could ever ask for....No one would use him but me, but it would be the dream.
I lie, for pitching I would love Pedro, Fernando, or Koufax.
You sound like a Dodgers fan, no love for Ramon Martinez? Raul Mondesi? Pedro Guerrero?
-
@formallyforearms said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@OreoRockstar said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Dodgers Steve Sax is all I could ever ask for....No one would use him but me, but it would be the dream.
I lie, for pitching I would love Pedro, Fernando, or Koufax.
You sound like a Dodgers fan, no love for Ramon Martinez? Raul Mondesi? Pedro Guerrero?
I am a Dodgers nut since I was 7 (1981). Loved Pedro, Mike Scioscia, Orel, Mariano Duncan, and the list goes on and on.
So would be stoked for any of the guys you mentioned, but Sax was my first sports hero, so that would be the be all end all.
-
Pedro over Clemens for the Sox. And I love Roger.
-
@bostondirtdog21 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Pedro over Clemens for the Sox. And I love Roger.
If I’m allowed to make one change on this list, it would be to replace Clemens with Pedro. Still can’t believe I left him off
-
Great list and idea for a topic.
Here's my own personal list:
Baltimore Orioles - Mike Mussina, SP
Boston Red Sox - Nomar Garciaparra, SS
New York Yankees - Roger Maris, RF
Tampa Bay Rays - James Shields, SP
Toronto Blue Jays - Roy Halladay, SPChicago White Sox - A.J. Pierzynski, C (or Magglio Ordonez, RF)
Cleveland Indians - Albert Belle, LF
Detroit Tigers - Prince Fielder, 1B
Kansas City Royals - Jermaine Dye, RF
Minnesota Twins - Joe Mauer, CLos Angeles Angels - Francisco "K-Rod" Rodriguez, CP
Oakland Athletics - Barry Zito, SP
Seattle Mariners - Randy Johnson, SP
Texas Rangers - Adrian Beltre, 3B
Houston Astros - Ken Caminiti, 3BAtlanta Braves - Hank Aaron, RF
Miami Marlins - Jose Fernandez, SP (or Dontrelle Willis, SP)
New York Mets - Dwight "Doc" Gooden, SP
Washington Nationals - Andres Galarraga, 1B
Philadelphia Phillies - Chase Utley, 2BChicago Cubs - Carlos Zambrano, SP
Cincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson, OF
Milwaukee Brewers - Ben Sheets, SP
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente, OF
St. Louis Cardinals - Carlos Beltran, OFArizona Diamondbacks - J.J. Putz, CP
Colorado Rockies - Troy Tulowitzki, SS
Los Angeles Dodgers - Hideo Nomo, SP
San Diego Padres - Jake Peavy, SP
San Francisco Giants - Tim Lincecum, SP -
Troy Glaus.
-
@BodamEscapePlan said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Great list and idea for a topic.
Here's my own personal list:
Baltimore Orioles - Mike Mussina, SP
Boston Red Sox - Nomar Garciaparra, SS
New York Yankees - Roger Maris, RF
Tampa Bay Rays - James Shields, SP
Toronto Blue Jays - Roy Halladay, SPChicago White Sox - A.J. Pierzynski, C
Cleveland Indians - Albert Belle, LF
Detroit Tigers - Prince Fielder, 1B
Kansas City Royals - Jermaine Dye, RF
Minnesota Twins - Joe Mauer, CLos Angeles Angels - Francisco "K-Rod" Rodriguez, CP
Oakland Athletics - Barry Zito, SP
Seattle Mariners - Randy Johnson, SP
Texas Rangers - Adrian Beltre, 3B
Houston Astros - Ken Caminiti, 3BAtlanta Braves - Hank Aaron, RF
Miami Marlins - Jose Fernandez, SP
New York Mets - Dwight "Doc" Gooden, SP
Washington Nationals - Andres Galarraga, 1B
Philadelphia Phillies - Chase Utley, 2BChicago Cubs - Carlos Zambrano, SP
Cincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson, OF
Milwaukee Brewers - Ben Sheets, SP
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente, OF
St. Louis Cardinals - Carlos Beltran, OFArizona Diamondbacks - J.J. Putz, CP
Colorado Rockies - Troy Tulowitzki, SS
Los Angeles Dodgers - Hideo Nomo, SP
San Diego Padres - Jake Peavy, SP
San Francisco Giants - Tim Lincecum, SPGreat list. Nomo would be very fun to use. Funny how you have Randy Johnson as a Mariner and JJ Putz as a D back. You could argue keeping both on the list but then just switching teams lol. Jose Fernandez should’ve been on my list. RIP.
-
Give me Al Simmons from the Philadelphia A’s, even over Waddell.
-
@Quint75 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Give me Al Simmons from the Philadelphia A’s, even over Waddell.
I’m actually surprised Al Simmons isn’t in the game already. He’d make my list, but Waddell would just be too much fun. If a player equipped a siren, he would run off the mound looking for the fire truck.
-
I’d love to have Pedro Martinez or Manny Ramirez
