Put together my starting 5 ....
-
I would go with
Orel
Seaver
Maddux
Paxton
And your choice of Lieter or KluberMost Nolan Ryan cards i've used have had shaky control. As for May i'm not sure necause i haven't used him but i don't think he has the staying power the other 5 guys in your rotaion have.
-
Honestly just keep the guys you cant sell. Paxton, Orel,lieter, seaver, and Kluber are a fine rotation if not great. Good balance of lefties vs righties and power vs finesse. Unless you love one of the other guys.
-
Yall really like paxton? I think he's garbage
-
I think Paxton might as well be an Astros, cuz for me he belongs in the
-
@James97M said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
Yall really like paxton? I think he's garbage
I agree I suck with him shocked I saw him in most of their choices !
-
Side note guys on Nolan Ryan...
I used him once he did well on All star but the guy wasn’t very good his control was annoying as frick though... I played against him on HOF and was pretty easy to read.. hard to catch up to his fastball but after a few innings it was easy..I wanna sell him but I also wanna use him one more time lol
-
@thehomiemiike said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
Side note guys on Nolan Ryan...
I used him once he did well on All star but the guy wasn’t very good his control was annoying as frick though... I played against him on HOF and was pretty easy to read.. hard to catch up to his fastball but after a few innings it was easy..I wanna sell him but I also wanna use him one more time lol
Honestly he's really bad, I wouldn't use more than once. He's good against bad players & horrible against good players or basically anyone who doesn't have a problem hitting heat.
-
Paxton is ridiculously underwhelming. Only time I used him was to prestige. Anytime I see I’m facing him in RS or event games I know I will score more runs that usual.
-
Newhouser
-
-
@thehomiemiike said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
@lazy_toast said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
Newhouser
He’s horrible too
Really ill take him over kluber and Paxton all day
-
@theman925 said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
Paxton is ridiculously underwhelming. Only time I used him was to prestige. Anytime I see I’m facing him in RS or event games I know I will score more runs that usual.
Yep. He's fine for offline, but online he gets crushed. Made me get Hamels (who's been great for me).
-
@ScaryLarito said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
@theman925 said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
Paxton is ridiculously underwhelming. Only time I used him was to prestige. Anytime I see I’m facing him in RS or event games I know I will score more runs that usual.
Yep. He's fine for offline, but online he gets crushed. Made me get Hamels (who's been great for me). Leiter is ok, but you should plan to prestige him if you do. Not enough velocity.
Edit: Sorry. Double post.
-
@thehomiemiike said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
I have
Kluber 99
Maddux 99
Nolan Ryan 99
Prestige Orel
Prestige leiter
Prestige Paxton
Dustin May
Seaver 99
I’m asking because I have a couple guys I could sell if they don’t fit in and I’m trying to put together a good 5 and sell the rest
If you want to add someone I don’t have please do so!IMO in no order id use Kluber Orel maddux seaver Leiter
-
In no specific order I’d say
Orel
Maddux
Prestige Leiter
Seaver
Kluber -
@thehomiemiike said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
I have
Kluber 99
Maddux 99
Nolan Ryan 99
Prestige Orel
Prestige leiter
Prestige Paxton
Dustin May
Seaver 99
I’m asking because I have a couple guys I could sell if they don’t fit in and I’m trying to put together a good 5 and sell the rest
If you want to add someone I don’t have please do so!My theory on this is to go with the guys that not everyone has experience hitting. At this point I feel Kluber is pretty predictable because I’ve seen him a 100 times. I’d say this would be my 5:
Orel
Ryan
Leiter
May
Seaver -
@mrwonderful95 said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
@thehomiemiike said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
I have
Kluber 99
Maddux 99
Nolan Ryan 99
Prestige Orel
Prestige leiter
Prestige Paxton
Dustin May
Seaver 99
I’m asking because I have a couple guys I could sell if they don’t fit in and I’m trying to put together a good 5 and sell the rest
If you want to add someone I don’t have please do so!My theory on this is to go with the guys that not everyone has experience hitting. At this point I feel Kluber is pretty predictable because I’ve seen him a 100 times. I’d say this would be my 5:
Orel
Ryan
Leiter
May
Seaver@mrwonderful95 said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
@thehomiemiike said in Put together my starting 5 ....:
I have
Kluber 99
Maddux 99
Nolan Ryan 99
Prestige Orel
Prestige leiter
Prestige Paxton
Dustin May
Seaver 99
I’m asking because I have a couple guys I could sell if they don’t fit in and I’m trying to put together a good 5 and sell the rest
If you want to add someone I don’t have please do so!My theory on this is to go with the guys that not everyone has experience hitting. At this point I feel Kluber is pretty predictable because I’ve seen him a 100 times. I’d say this would be my 5:
Orel
Ryan
Leiter
May
SeaverAppreciate your input but... you only seen kluber 100times? Lol that’s it?
-
My Rotation as of today:
- Cy Young Cory Cluber
- Potm James Paxton
- SS Hal Newhouser
- Topps Shane Bieber
- Cy Young King Felix.
-
Only one I don’t like is May. I think he’s easy to hit. I haven’t used Seaver or Ryan yet. I love Orel. I have a tough time hitting Maddux who I haven’t used either. I’m hit or miss with Leiter but I like him. Paxton has been coming around.
-
A admin locked this topic on
