Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?
-
3rd base and it's not even a question. That's where I've played Sheffield almost exclusively and I don't think I'll move him.
-
I agree tho on Prestige Sheff at 3B and actually have been running out Prestige Chipper at SS when I don't have Prestige Didi out there. Brett is nice but not on the offensive level as Sheff so just comes down to what you value more. For me, I live and die by the HR so I prefer power over defense when choices are close as I'm not that great a hitter so need all the power and contact that a hitter can give me.
-
I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.
-
As good as Brett’s swing is I use regular Sheffield. It turns out I mash with the dude. He also rarely makes errors
-
@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.
I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out
-
@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.
I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out
Higher contact=larger inside contact area means its easier to square balls up. Also has a sweet swing.
-
@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.
I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out
Higher contact=larger inside contact area means its easier to square balls up. Also has a sweet swing.
Yeah, I get bailed out by the maxed out vision/high contact he’s got lol. Also he’s got a sweet swing!
-
@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.
I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out
Higher contact=larger inside contact area means its easier to square balls up. Also has a sweet swing.
Yeah, I get bailed out by the maxed out vision/high contact he’s got lol. Also he’s got a sweet swing!
Also me being trash and playing on all-star helps too hahaha -
I would platoon them, I do a Brett and Killebrew platoon and I love both of their bats. Whoever isn't starting ends up being a badass bench bat
-
@Sayjinman said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:
I’ll have Prestige Sheff soon and I’ve been using him at 3B with no real problems defensively so far. Been using TA Brett at 1B until I get Musial. Once I get Musial, who do I move to 3B? My OF is LF Mantle, CF Super Trout, RF Walker so there is no room for Sheff in the OF. What do y’all think?
I dont have TA Brett but I'm inclined to move my Sheff to 3B to put a better defender in RF (Potm Belli is my best option right now). I love Vet/Prestige Chipper but I think he may become a bench bat for me.
Main question is....who do you hit better with? Thats the guy who should be in your lineup as a starter. Use the other as a pinch hitter.
-
A admin locked this topic on
