@Ouija131933_XBL Not sure if you're still having this issue... I was having the same issue as 2B. I even took screenshots of the errors and saved video of it happening. But what fixed it was just leveling up my Fielding score some more. And for ShowTime events... once I hit 'X' I didn't hit any other buttons... the player will automatically aim at a base and give you 1 of the 2 accuracy tests (reticle or the button sequence test).
I didn't have to level my fielding too much before it kicked in. I want to say 60+, but def 65+ was fine. (Fielding is a miracle stat if you're actually fielding. At 50 you feel like it's your first time ever having a ball hit in your direction and at 80 you feel like a wizard.)