Community Forum

Ok thank you I’ll probably end up doing that and just hoping it works , I’ve read things about people changing settings in their router but I don’t want to do all that or get a vpn just to play an online game.

Yes Xbox live is all good on that end , every game I have lets me play online like Madden, call of duty , battlefield , Fortnite etc, but for some reason mlb never fixed this issue with the tmobile WiFi because I have read so many threads and messages with people never getting a fix for it.

I just got mlb the show a couple days ago and have had the games in the past, spent time grinding for a team to play online diamond dynasty and everytime I try and load into an online game I get an “challenge failed” message which is basically an error or disconnection message. I’ve been reading people have been having this problem for years now on mlb the show with tmobile home WiFi, please fix and let us play the game with tmobile WiFi just like every other game on the market lets us do.

December 2025, few days before Christmas. I have T-Mobile WiFi and the issue of “challenge failed” while trying to load into an online game is still so bad , I’ve had the game for a couple days now and am just disoriented after reading peoples comments from mlb the show 23 and it still has never been fixed , how has it never been fixed? It’s so easy and simple why do they continue to ignore and ignore this.