Community Forum

In year's past I've always have had a rankings system that I've always posted to give advice and a different prospective to players. Some of these rankings surely most of you will disagree with...but hey they're my rankings and I'm willing to take the heat/debate. Also these are my rankings using the players not facing them. Please note that* refers to secondary position and P! Refers to Prestige.

Rankings

SP

1. P! O.Hershiser
2. C.Kluber
3. P!J.Paxton
4. P! K.Wood
5. H.Newhouser

Just missed - Maddux/Feller

RP

1. R.Dibble
2. P! M.Rivera
3. A.Chapman
4. R.Fingers
5. B.Wagner

Just missed - Rodney/Gossage/Henke

Catcher

1.P! C.Biggio*
2. C.Biggio*
3. CAP
4. J.Posada
5. Gary! - If you even sniff the [censored] ball its gone.

If Pablo wasn't so horrible on defense he would make the cut. Also why Gary is lower.

1st Base (Can be secondary)

1. P! C.Bellinger
2. P! F.McGriff
3. M.Thames
4. J.Thome
5. 99 J.Ramirez*
   (Ortiz SUCKS!!)

2nd Base

1. CAP
2. 99 J.Robinson
3. 99 J.Ramirez*
4. 97 R.Cano
5. P! R.Sandberg

Shortstop

1.CAP
2. P! D.Gregorius
3. P! C.Correa
4. C.Ripkin
5. 88 T.Anderson (I just rake with this card)

Ernie Banks is awful!

3rd Base

1. E.Mathews (Smoothest swing ever! I don't use him currently for the reason of lineup balance)
2. !P G.Sheffield *
3. !P.H.Killabrew
4. P! C.Jones
5. P! M.Scmidt

Outfield

1. M. Mantle(s)
2. 99 M.Trout
3. P! L.Walker
4. P! C.Bellinger*
5. P! R.Jackson
6. P! J.Ellsberry
7. 95 M.Trout
8. P! E.Davis
9. HRD K.Griffey Jr.
10. P! L.Brock (Just someone about his swing the ball MOVES) + a single turns into a triple.

Stan the man just missed the cut, he would be #11.....but I guess that makes him technically overrated. #12/#13 would be McCutchen/Blackmon (that [censored] swing)

Most overrated outfield award goes to....J.D Martinez! I HATE both cards

Gun to my head I have to pick 3 of each to start a BR draft.

1.M.Mantle
2.M.Trout
3.C.Biggio

1. O.Hershiser
2. R.Dibble
3. M.Rivera

Pitchers/Batters I love/hate facing

Hitters (hate facing)

1. Reggie Jackson!!!
2. M.Mantle
3. C.Biggio

Pitchers (hate facing)

1. James Paxton - Cutter,FB,Sinker combo gives me fits!
2. O.Hershiser
3. 99 A.Chapman

Hitters (Love facin)

1. JD Martinez! - He is probably 0-18 at least vs me.
2. D.Ortiz - only gave up 1 HR to him in ABs
3. E.Davis - I hit great with him, but vs him its a bowling ball vs a twig.

Pitchers (Love facing)

1. F.Hernandez
2. 99 C.Mize
3. R.Dibble (No idea why, but I just crush him)

I don't mind I take the easy out and move on. When I see Jackie or Brock come up I put on bunt defense. Out of probably 50 bunts maybe 2 have been safe.

For me CAP is a clear cut #1, but Didi is second for me. I think Banks is extremely overrated card.

@allday9128 said in I am in need of help:

You should probably take his PSN ID out of the post would be the biggest help I could give

Thank you I did that.

I am currently in a freeze off with another player and he is doing this on purpose. His last bunch of games online have been 0-0 victories! I took screenshots of these games, What is the best way to send these screenshots to someone that can do something about this.

Do not waste your stubs on this card! I've used it and played against (my son had the card). I thought to myself that this will be the lefty Kluber and it is not! You don't hear
youtubers or anyone talking about it because people are making a ton of stubs off of it. I would honestly rather Hal or Lodolo.

I have struggled badly with 99 Sheffield for some reason.

Lazaro if your playing in higher levels of difficulty. If you are an average player and wanna gas up Noobs by all means get Kopech.

i really want Joe Morgan. Joe Carter won't crack my lineup.

he's awful leave him on the bench

Sell him unless you plan on doing collections

I think they buffed the sliders on showdown...plain and simple and everything that I've read about it 90%, of the people are done with it. I think eventually they'll adjust it back to what it was.

Well I won't be playing that mode again.

I've played and beat showdown about 20+ times already and only failed twice. I hop on to play a few to get a few more affinities done and the mode now seems impossible! The pitchers straight up DOT just about every single pitch even in the early missions. This mode was a lot of fun to grind out players and now it seems like your playing a top player each round.