Community Forum

Hey everyone,

I just finished up a game and I had some weird issue with the pitch releases. I use pure analog to pitch, and I had these issues with all four of the pitchers I used. The issue was probably about 50% of the time on breaking pitches. No issues with fastballs. When I pulled the stick down, and then push it back up once it hit the line, the immediate feedback would be ‘good’ timing. However, the ball would be in the dirt or way outside. Then, after the pitch, in the little window where it shows where the pitch was, the timing of your release and batter exit velo etc., it kept reading as I was releasing it ‘too late’.

Anyone have this issue before? Any potential solutions? Thanks!

It’s the middle of November and I’m still using 86 Ryan McMahon lol. Dude is a beast. Lars Nootbaar also is underrated imo

Hey y’all, I’m trying to calculate if I need to buy more players but I’ve done all the existing exchanges so I cannot see the exchange value of the different overalls. Is there a spreadsheet with this info, or does anyone happen to know? I’ve got 88’s 89’s and 91’s so far.
Thanks I’m advance!

Can anyone tell me what the new event reward is? I haven’t been able to hop on my PlayStation since it started.

If anyone faces a dude whose name is “grand slam with Freddie freeman and I quit” don’t do it, took advantage of me feeling nice tonight. His name was like Esteban bughati or something like that. Just a heads up so no one else gets burned

Anyone have an issue with their best hitters going into a slump after using them for so long? For example the 99 Nick Castellanos was my best hitter for quite a while, he was hitting like .375 at one time, but as of late, (maybe his last 75-100 at bats) he’s been bad, his average has gone down to .315

I’ve had similar slumps with players like 96 Yaz, 99 Jackie, 99 Nolan but not as drastic.

Should I just bench them for a few games and see if I’m more fresh when them then?

If you’ve had this issue, I’d love to hear how you fixed it.

For anyone who watched KevinGOHD and Dimmu play, any ideas on how dimmu used that glitch (if it’s not patched already)?

Last night I offered a guy a friendly before the game as he had an insane team and record, and people playing that late are always crazy good. He declined it, and he eventually quit once I got up 8-3 in the 8th inning. Felt pretty good.

I’m extremely thankful that I got to 500 stars in the 11th inning program yesterday and sold the fifth inning boss for 120 K. For the first time the MLB The Show gods were watching out for me.

Chipper Jones. Can’t hit with him from either side of the plate. Never have been able to. But if my opponent has him and I’m throwing a lefty, it’s an automatic home run, so that contributes to my dislike of his cards

@eatyum said in Stealing:

I'll throw the question back at you in reverse. Why should perfect throws have to result in outs?

I’m not saying it should be an automatic out by any means. If they get a good jump, I’ll gladly tip my cap, But if the ball beats the runner on a perfect throw they should be out a majority of the time.

I played a game earlier today where I had a guy stealing left and right on me. 3 different times, I made a perfect throw to second or third and even though the ball beat him, a hook slide made him safe each time. Anyone else have this issue? What’s the point of having a ‘perfect’ throw when a hook slide just automatically makes them safe.

For those who have played MLB the show for multiple seasons, what one or two of your favorite cards from past games? For it, going way back, in 2016, live series Carlos Gonzalez was by far my favorite card. 97 Josh Hamilton was also a favorite from that year. Immortal trout in 2018 was pretty great too.

Has anyone used him much? I did well with his prospect card, plus I normally do well with cards with outlier. Is he worth the price?

@Seeber_97 said in Too many stubs:

I made a post like this maybe a month ago, but I have more stubs than I know what to do with. I’ve got about 750 K, I have Trout, Mantle, and Lindor already. For the first time all year all 5 guys in my rotation are doing decent, and same with my bullpen. I’ve got a few platoons in the field, but I have no idea what i should do with my stubs.

I’ve thought about trying out the new Arrieta or maybe the new Kopech. But if y’all have any particular favorite or underrated cards, I’d love to hear! Thanks for the input.

Edit: I also have almost every TA to 100, I only have maybe 7 or 8 that are like 80% or more

I made a post like this maybe a month ago, but I have more stubs than I know what to do with. I’ve got about 750 K, I have Trout, Mantle, and Lindor already. For the first time all year all 5 guys in my rotation are doing decent, and same with my bullpen. I’ve got a few platoons in the field, but I have no idea what i should do with my stubs.

I’ve thought about trying out the new Arrieta or maybe the new Kopech. But if y’all have any particular favorite or underrated cards, I’d love to hear! Thanks for the input.

I SWEAR IT HAPPENED

I had a guy quit in the event because I hit a grand slam with Paxton (yes, the pitcher) and he quit before the ball landed so technically it didn’t count. I was a bit upset

So I noticed Griffey went from like 220K up to like 320K since the 11th inning program came out. Is he going to sit right around 320 or will he continue to rise?

Also similar question with the RIB cards. Specifically Hader, he started at 170 or so, and now he’s like 95. Do you think now that people have had a chance to play it a bit, his price will stay around 90? Or will it go down.

Any thoughts are appreciated, thanks!

I almost took Kluber deep with finest DeGrom the other day. Hooked foul right at the last second