@tonythetiger2k16 said in Million $$ "EA" Question ...:
However "IF" EA did get it right & hit a Home-Run & releases a game that is BETTER in every way over MLBTS with it's Game Play, Mechanics, Features, Modes, Content, Etc & it was mostly DLC Purchase based.
I think the biggest thing is the "if" of this statement. EA can't even make a good game right now on their other sports franchises. Madden and FIFA both have borderline game-breaking bugs in glitches and that's just in offline modes. SDS may have it's share of bugs but I can at least play offline with little to none complications.
EA is also going to have issue breaking in to a market that is already existing. They tried to make a comeback with their NBA Live series and couldn't make a big enough dent in 2K's sales to warrant keeping it going, ending the endeavor after only a few years. And even that game, meticulously worked on to try and be better than 2K, grew stale and boring rather quickly and offered nothing new. I would argue that the baseball video game market is not the biggest to begin with so when someone already has the market cornered, you would have to operate at a loss the first few years just to even take away a fraction of the player base.
I don't believe that they can offer much, if anything, more than SDS at this point. Trying to fix Madden's franchise mode has been a point of contention for years, and even with the latest installment where they claimed that it was the deepest and most immersive in recent years, it really did not bring much new to the table and is a surface level simulation at best. Their Face of the Franchise mode makes such a focus on being narrative driven, that you lose any replay-ability. Aside from what position you play, starting another player career doesn't change anything, whereas MLBTS allows you to have several careers going on with different positions if you so feel inclined without recycling cutscenes and letting you get right into the action.
Lastly, and this may just be me, but SDS has released a ton of content that is all free. I have not had to pay for anything to get some of the best cards in the game and really only bought stubs to finish some collections since I don't play online modes at all. Meanwhile, EA nearly forces you to buy extra content to get some slightly better cards than what you have.
So if you're asking if I think EA could even make a better game? No. If they somehow did, would I buy it? No. I don't want to look at my bank statement and wonder how I spent at least $100 on top of the $60 game to have an 85 OVR team when I can also spend $60 on The Show and never purchase anything else and still feel like I am on par with people that spend money.
Apologies for the long post. Thanks for reading.