• Categories
  • Popular
  • Dev Tracker
Skins
  • Default (The Show 25)
  • No Skin
  • The Show 23
  • Dark
  • The Show 24
  • The Show 25
Collapse
THESHOW.COM
Game Game Support Support My Account My Account

Community Forum

olivegarden2_PSNO

olivegarden2_PSN

@olivegarden2_PSN
About
Posts
2.4k
Topics
159

Posts

Recent Best Controversial

    Long list of best cards at each position
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Ok...I created a list of the best players at each position. They are ranked in order from best to the worst. Use this if you need help for you team! I would also like feedback if I missed anyone or you disagree! This is all from my experience and some from others. A CAP is also an option for each position if you don't like any options

    Note: CM= community market

    Another note: when the price is free there is some grinding involved. It takes time to get those cards but doesn't cost any stubs

    And..another note: TA3 cards can be free but you have the option to buy them as well

    Catchers:
    1 99 Posey | Xp reward path | Price: free!
    2 96 Wieters | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 45k
    3 98 Molina | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 70k
    4 99 Biggio (secondary) LS AL collection | Price: roughly 600k to complete the AL collection
    5 95 Pablo (secondary)| Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    6 96 Posada | Beach Ball base round/CM | Price: roughly 25k
    7 98 Torre | 4th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 80k
    8 99 Gary Carter | BR 12-0 reward/CM | Price: roughly 250k
    9 97 Kendall | TA3 Pirates/CM | Price: roughly 30k

    First base:
    1 The Babe (secondary)| Old Timer Program | Price: free!!!!!
    2 99 Thames | prestige xp reward path | Price: free!
    3 99 Papi | 5th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 130k
    4 99 Thome | TA3 Indians/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    5 99 Musial (secondary) |6th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 110k
    6 97 Belli | June POTM lightning | Price: free!
    7 98 Pete Alonso | HRD set 2 rare round/CM | Price: roughly 100k
    8 98 Mcgriff | TA3 Rays/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    9 Either Giambi (92/93) | Yankees LS collection or HRD set 1 base/CM Price: roughly 200k to complete Yanks collection or roughly 10k on market
    10 Edwin 95 | Showdown starter 2 | Price: free!
    11 Bagwell 99 | TA3 Astros/CM | Price: roughly 40k
    12 94 Kirilloff | TA2 Twins | | Price: free!

    2nd base:
    1 99 Hornsby | Beach Ball rare/CM | Price: roughly 110k
    2 Biggio 99 | LS AL collection | Price: roughly 600k to complete the LS AL collection
    3 97 Cano | HRD set 1 rare/CM | Price: roughly 60k
    4 99 Jackie | His own free evolution player program | Price: free!
    5 95 Madrigal | old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 15k
    6 94 Murphy | DOTP base/CM | Price: roughly 12k
    7 94 Zobrist | Old BR reward/CM | Price: roughly 200k
    8 98 Carew | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 40k
    9 Brian Roberts 94 | 3rd inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 60k
    10 Vidal Brujan 95 | TA2 Rays | Price: free!

    SS:
    1 93 Didi | April POTM lightning diamond | Price: free!
    2 99 Rollins | 6th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 110k
    3 99 Banks | DOTP Elite/CM | Price: roughly 150k
    4 94 Jazz | TA2 Marlins | Price: free!
    5 96 Kieboom | old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    6 99 Yount | TA3 Brewers/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    7 J Ram 99 | Prestige XP reward path | Price: free!
    8 95 Correa | May POTM lightning | Price: free!
    9 99 Larkin Rips | Xp reward path | Price: free!
    10 98 Trammel | old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 40k

    3rd base:
    1 Chipper 94 | 3rd inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 40k
    2 97 Bryant | old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 100k
    3 99 Eddie | WS reward/CM | Price: roughly 150k
    4 99 Donaldson | BR reward/CM | Price: roughly 500k
    5 99 Killebrew | TA3 Twins/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    6 95 Correa (secondary) | May POTM lightning | Price: free!
    7 Gorman 95 | TA2 Cards | Price: free!
    8 Schmidt 99 | TA3 Phillies/CM | Price: roughly 60k
    9 Pablo 95 | old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    10 George Brett 99 | TA3 Royals/CM | Price: roughly 50k

    Outfield
    1 Mantle 99 | LS MLB collection | Price: roughly 1.2 million stubs to complete the LS collection for the best card in the game
    2 Trout 99 | Legends and flashbacks collection | Price: roughly 750k-1.5 million stubs to complete the L and F collection
    3 Walker 99 | 5th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 130k
    4 Eric Davis 98 | TA3 Reds/CM | Price: roughly 45k
    5 Andre Dawson 99 | TA3 Nats/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    6 Springer 99 | Prestige XP reward path | Price: free!
    7 98 Griffey (HRD) | HRD collection | Price: roughly 400k to complete the HRD collection
    8 97 Carlson | old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 60k
    9 Rickey Henderson | WS reward | Price: roughly 500k but will go down to 250k eventually
    10 99 Robert | beach ball rare/cm | price: roughly 100k
    11 Sheffield 99 | LS NL collection | Price: roughly 600k to complete the LS NL collection
    12 99 Adell | DOTP Elite/CM | Price: roughly 130k
    13 Ellsbury 96 | 4th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    14 Kaline 99 | TA3 Tigers/CM | Price: roughly 55k
    15 Pache | Old headliner/cm | Price: 70k
    16 95 Trout (LS) | CM | Price: roughly 225k
    17Vlad SR 99 | WS reward/CM | Price: roughly 150k
    18 Evans 98 | TA3 Red Sox/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    17 Judge 97 | HRD set 2 rare/CM | Price: roughly 100k
    18 97 Cespedes | HRD set 1 rare/CM | Price: roughly 70k
    19 Kemp 97 | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    20 Reggie 99 | XP reward path | Price: free!
    21 Brock 98 | TA3 Cards/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    22 Gwynn 99 | TA3 Padres/CM | Price: roughly 40k
    23 Cutch 97 | DOTP Mid/CM | Price: roughly 25k
    24 J Hey 95 | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 25k
    25 Trammel 94 | TA2 Padres | Price: free!
    26 Stanton 97 | Set 1 HRD/CM | Price: roughly 75k
    27 Minoso 99 | XP reward path | Price: free!
    28 Foster 97 | WS reward/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    29 D Parker 98 | old BR 12-0 reward | Price: roughly 200k
    30 Buhner | TA3 Mariners/CM | Price: roughly 30k

    Starters:
    1 Orel 98 (he is the best pitcher in the game...I'm saying it again lol) | TA3 Dodgers/CM | Price: roughly 65k
    2 Kluber 99 | XP reward path | Price: free!
    3 Sale 99 | WS reward | Price: roughly 550k but should go down to 275k
    4 Feller 99 | BR 12-0 reward/CM | Price: roughly 400k
    5 Hamels 96 | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 35k
    6 Mize 99 | BR 12-0 reward/CM | Price: roughly 300k
    7 Lodolo 95 | TA2 Reds | Price: free!
    8 Wood 97 | TA3 Cubs | Price: roughly 60k
    9 95 Glavine | Old BR 12-0 reward/CM | Price: roughly 200k
    10 99 Maddux | 6th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 110k
    11 97 Leiter | TA3 Mets/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    12 Hal 98 | XP reward path | Price: free!
    13 Paxton | July POTM lightning | Price: free!
    14 Sutton 97 | Current headliner/CM | Price: roughly 35k
    15 McKay 98 | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 50k
    16 S Howard 96 | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 20k
    17 Felix 96 | 4th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    18 Burnett 97 | TA3 Marlins/CM | Price: roughly 30k
    19 M Scott 99 | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 20k
    20 Greinke 97 | DOTP Mid/CM | Price: roughly 25k
    Lefties in the pen:

    1 97 Chapman | DOTP Elite/CM | Price: roughly 150k
    2 90 France | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 40k
    3 Britton 93 | Old WS reward/CM | Price: roughly 60k
    4 94 Wagner | LS AL west collection | Price: roughly 350k to complete the LS AL west collection
    5 85 Chapman | CM | Price: roughly 8k
    6 91 Miller | Old BR reward/CM | Price: roughly 100k
    7 95 Mcgee | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 45k
    8 Alvarado 85 | 5th inning henchman/CM | Price: roughly 10k
    9 Hader 88 | CM | Price: roughly 12k
    10 88 Doolittle | A's LS collection | Price: roughly 10k to complete the A's LS collection

    Righties in the pen:
    1 95 Dibble |Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 100k
    2 98 Gagne | Beach Ball base | Price: roughly 25k
    3 99 Mo | 5th inning boss/CM | Price: roughly 130k
    4 96 Rollie | Xp reward path | Price: free!
    5 92 Gagne | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 20k
    6 97 Henke | TA3 Jays/CM | Price: roughly 70k
    7 92 Rodney | DOTP base/CM | Price: roughly 15k
    8 93 Eck | Evolution program unlocked through the XP reward path | Price: free!
    9 95 Betances | Old event reward/CM | Price: roughly 70k
    10 92 Nenn | Old headliner/CM | Price: roughly 15k

    Thanks for reading, I hope you like guys my list!


  • People Using Lefty Pitchers in Event
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Another thread about this. If you can't hit commons you have a huge problem


  • Officially done carrying about my RS record
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Officially done reading these complaining posts with no reasoning


  • Hi, my name is Buck
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Hi, my name is Olive Garden breadsticks and we are open for takeout.


  • Conquest should be implemented more into DD
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    I made a thread earlier asking the community their favorite DD game mode. A bunch of people said conquest was fun. I agree! It is not too stressful. I hope SDS can put this into team affinities. Maybe add divisional maps and if you finish it that is 10 points towards every team in that division or something like that. It should take more time than showdown I think but less time than MTO. @Collin_SDS @Victor_SDS @SDS_Jax can you guys think about doing this? Thanks!


  • Today’s content
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    So last night I made a list for today’s content. I even included some card art with stick figures lol. I did this before they announced the BP and Pache. So I also put an Adam Dunn card possibility. Here you guys go: https://docs.google.com/document/d/12r5LMqNk99kiCqwIZUM_afNIMOjBzprIhthPIy513UU/edit. Edit: I think I juiced that BP too much. He is only getting a 93. That “card” had way better hitting stats than his 95 last year


  • To everyone that thing the Ruth program is too challenging
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    It should be a little bit lol. He is still free and you get packs, stubs, xp, and other cards. HOF isn't actually that difficult. I'm surprised there aren't any legend games. Be happy the cards are free everyone!


  • Um SDS this isn’t like you!
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    You guys gave me 2 diamonds in 1 pack (ballin)! I’ve pulled 4 diamonds in the last week after none since the beginning of the year! Thank you and I will be quiet about my luck now! 90+ incoming soon! I hope everyone is getting blessed by the pack gods!


  • Joe Kelly is a bonafide Troll
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Joe Kelly fight club...I remember that lol


  • Conquest for TA 3
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    People like the idea SDS. Maybe you guys could make divisional maps and you get 10 TA points (voucher) towards a team in that division once you complete it. That is how I think conquest should go into TA


  • Pssst! SDS!! Wanna make a few hundo???
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Now my turn:

    My dearest, SDS

    I will buy any of the following for the collection coming soon
    1 Griffey JR
    2 Willie Mays
    3 Dimaggio
    4 Hank Aaron
    5 Yaz
    6 Ted
    7 Bartolo
    8 Clemente
    NONE OF THESE BELOW
    1 Jeter
    2 Jeter
    3 Jeter
    4 Jeter
    5 Piazza
    6 any others just use one on my list!

    Please listen SDS and thank you for your time!

    Yours truely,

    Mr. Olive Garden Breadsticks


  • Why Doesn't Maddux Have 2 Seam?
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    @The_Icon148 said in Why Doesn't Maddux Have 2 Seam?:

    @olivegarden2 said in Why Doesn't Maddux Have 2 Seam?:

    @PoopsyMcDoodle said in Why Doesn't Maddux Have 2 Seam?:

    @doomtrain69 said in Why Doesn't Maddux Have 2 Seam?:

    Because he has a sinker......a better version in-game of the same exact pitch

    Nope wrong

    2 seam is horizontal and the sinker is a verticalbreak

    IRL they are. I can tell you that because I throw a 2 seamer and it's different from a sinker. But in this game a 2 seamer is a poor mans sinker

    Irl underhand pitching leagues dont count.

    I play year round competitive baseball, play tourneys and I'm a kid still...


  • 5k from Mantle lol
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Going to bed right now can’t wait to get him Tomorrow!!


  • I’ve been Springered...
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    You guys know I don’t pull many diamonds around here! I have to admit it’s a great troll though...


  • Recap of the update
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    There have been a bunch of threads about parts of the update but this one will recap the whole thing. Let’s get started:
    New diamonds: Luke Voit, Starling Marte, and Kenta Maeda

    New golds: Didi, Teoscar, Heyward, Robert, Happ, Hosmer, Kiermier and Glasnow

    Headliner: 99 FS Royce Lewis
    Topps now: Myers, Deivi Garcia, Rosario, Sogard, and Solano.

    Player program: 96 gold glove Torri hunter

    Henchmen: FS Ian Anderson, FS Sean Murphy, and FS Mitch Keller (all 96’s)

    Bosses: 99 gold glove pudge, 99 prime Ty Cobb, and 99 cy young Kershaw. All prestigable

    Last headliner will be next week as well.

    POTM coming next Friday (9/11)

    Conquest: duck map. Note: capture the tigers stronghold on the first turn.

    Dead ball event coming next week as well! I’m actually not excited lol

    All standard packs are 50% off

    Anyways, I post all of this stuff on my discord ASAP. If you would like to join the discord, pm me! Enjoy the update everyone!


  • Lol A rod
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    He just called Gio Urshela the best defensive 3rd baseman in the AL lol. Ever heard of Matt Chapman?


  • Yes, I finally got him
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    TROUT, IN POSSESSION! Some of you guys have seen my posts about getting close to Trout. I got him today for 308k, a good deal in my eyes


  • July POTM
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Give me a James Paxton please not another trash can banger for the lightning


  • Why do people bunt dance?
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    Bunt dancers get to enjoy my replays. I especially love replaying on them when Didi hits a no doubter lol


  • Showdown run time
  • olivegarden2_PSNO olivegarden2_PSN

    In my opinion it takes too long for a run. I just spent 1 hour and a half going through the 6th inning showdown. I did all right through the missions. I went into the final showdown and hit into 3 perfect perfect outs. I had 1 perfect perfect land. The RNG can be crazy and it makes it hard for me to want to play showdown if I’m putting in a bunch of time and getting no reward for it. @Collin_SDS @Victor_SDS @Pat_SDS

X Instagram Facebook YouTube Twitch Discord TikTok
Major League Baseball Players Association Major League Baseball Sony Interactive Entertainment PlayStation Studios San Diego Studio ESRB ESRB Certificate
Terms of Use Privacy Policy TheShow.com Community Code of Conduct MLB The Show Online Code of Conduct MLB The Show Games

Stubs is a registered trademark or trademark of Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC.

"PlayStation Family Mark", "PlayStation", "PS5 Logo", and "PS4 Logo" are registered trademarks or trademarks of Sony Interactive Entertainment Inc.

Microsoft, the Xbox Sphere mark, Series X|S logo, and Xbox Series X|S are trademarks of the Microsoft group of companies.

Nintendo Switch is a trademark of Nintendo.

Major League and Minor League Baseball trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of Major League Baseball. Visit MLB.com and MiLB.com. The Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Inc., as applicable. Visit the official website of the Hall of Fame at BaseballHall.org

Officially Licensed Product of MLB Players, Inc. MLBPA trademarks, copyrighted works and other intellectual property rights are owned and/or held by MLBPA and may not be used without the written consent of MLBPA or MLB Players, Inc. Visit MLBPLAYERS.com, the Players Choice on the web.

© 2024 Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC.

  • Login

  • Login or register to search.
  • First post
    Last post
0
  • Categories
  • Popular
  • Dev Tracker
  • Login

  • Login or register to search.