Okay, I've solved my problem and hopefully, I can help some of you with this information.
My original RTTS player was a Contact/SS. I ran the Contact program line to the Gold tier. My buddy made a catcher to start and we realized there wasn't one ballplayer for our overall use and we would upgrade individually like last year. With this, I started my own catcher and created a POWER archetype. I made the decision to continue my Contact program so I made ANOTHER catcher with CONTACT.
I now have 3 ballplayer profiles made:
Contact SS
Power C
Contact C
I have only 2 save files. Both are my contact profiles. I never started the season for my lone power profile. At some point of continuing my contact grind on my catcher I manually saved another file which created 3 save files. One for my shortstop and two for my CONTACT catcher. I have the two saves at different points of my contact catcher season. Don't ask me why I did this I have no idea. It is my assumption that the second save, the manual save, was attached to the power profile. I continued playing with my gold contact catcher on this new save profile and it was progressing my "Bronze Power" program line. I've since deleted the POWER profile and continued on the original save file. I'm back to progressing my gold contact program.
It would be very easy to say I messed up, but I never started the power season nor did I swap back to it after starting my contact catcher. That and I've only ever had 2 save files for my RTTS seasons, contact and contact.
Hopefully this confusion helps anyone thats finds the post having a similar problem.