Community Forum

Willie was the best card in 19 imo. the best catchers imo were Piazza and Posada

Mookie is the best imo

People who pause after every pitch are just trying to [censored] the opponent off.

I don't have him, but he terrorizes me whenever I face him

I just got him in the event and I have no inclination of selling him

He's def not worth it, but he's a rare card and most rare cards this year sell for a million stubs.

I actually like D'Arnaud, he smashes for me out of the 8 hole. But I know I'm in the minority.

I love Verlander irl, but sadly he's never been able to get it done in MLB the Show

I agree, I love Nenn cards, but it's silly how similar they are. In fact some may say the 92 is better. I think they should have gave the 95 outlier on his fb

Hoffman is decent online, def not one of the best relievers, but he's more than serviceable. Just stick to the cutter, 4seamer and Slider. People sit on his change up and crush it.

If I am remembering correctly, It used to be stupid easy to rob a homer in 18. I'm actually kinda happy it's really rare to rob homeruns.

I've played about 25 games in the event. I'd say I've faced Bauer or Darvish about 20 out of those 25 games lol

99 Feller is bad IMO unless you use him on legend. Never used 99 Carter but this is kind of like comparing apples to tangerines.

Agreed his swing is butter

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Piazza or Realmuto?:

You’re going to take a major hit on defense, but if you don’t hit well with Realmuto then it could be worth the boost in offense.

Im hitting about .330 or so with Realmuto online which is decent for me, so if Piazza is a force at the dish i'd take the defensive hit

Was wondering if Piazza would be much of an upgrade over Finest Realmuto? He's been a solid catcher for me