I've been having this same issue on All-Star pitching difficulty with API turned on as well. It shows up on certain pitches in the count, but usually not the first pitch and just kind of randomly throughout the at-bat. I even went back to The Show 19 to make sure I wasn't just remembering it wrong, but no something is screwed up with the game at this moment.

Yeah it's probably just an early version issue that may get fixed eventually. It's definitely not game-breaking for me, but it IS a little annoying and something I noticed.

Unfortunately that doesn't fix it. I think it's just some sort of bug that will have to be fixed. I've never had this happen in a previous iteration of The Show and I've been using the same settings for years.

When I play in Franchise mode on All-Star pitching difficulty with API turned on the suggested pitch location only sometimes is displayed. I'm not sure if this issue happens in any other mode or difficulty because I haven't really messed with my settings once I got them where I wanted. I know in previous years the location suggestion shows up on every single pitch when I have API turned "On". Any ideas?