I figured out a work around. Whenever you think a reliever should be out, pause, go to Next Appearance but immediately stop it (Square on PS5). Then select Enter Game to go immediately back in. This triggers the game to put the pitcher in that would be in if you were just playing the highlight moments. It’s been working for me. Sometimes you’ll do it and there’s no change so I just do it when I think there would be a new pitcher on the mound.
K
kiloforty_PSN
@kiloforty_PSN