@TheBigPapa55_PSN
Fair enoughâwe'll put you down for a tentative 'maybe' on the pre-order then. 
JamezBonnie_PSN
Posts
-
-
Fair points on Stadium Creator and SDS letting offline modes sit stagnantâthat's actually why I'd love to see them take a real swing at hockey, because someone needs to challenge EA.
Where I think we're talking past each other is on the NHL sliders: I wasn't trying to make the game easier or harder, I was trying to separate my Pro from my AI teammates. Even with all of EA's slider depth, the "Human" sliders still apply to the entire team whenever we have the puck. So the second I bump passing, skating, or shooting so my prospect actually plays like an elite superstar, my 3rd-line AI teammates suddenly turn into the 1980s Oilers dynasty too and start scoring on every shot. Imagine getting drafted to Vancouverâwho are sitting at 3-16-1 right nowâand suddenly we go undefeated just because I bumped my own player's sliders. One new rookie shouldn't mean the Canucks suddenly turn into an undefeated powerhouse. That's the exact "magic wand" problemâin The Show, my individual at-bats and pitching appearances are isolated from the rest of the lineup, whereas NHL doesn't let you tune your created player independently from the AI roster around you.
Just my opinion, but if SDS ever built a hockey game with that kind of player-isolated progression and brought their Stadium Creator mindset to custom arenasâeven if the rink dimensions are standardized, everything around the glass, boards, lighting, and atmosphere is wide openâit would push EA to actually innovate instead of recycling the same Be a Pro quirks every year. -
I know this is a massive long shot bringing up another sport on The Show forums, and I know building a brand-new sports franchise from scratch takes yearsâbut after playing MLB The Show 26, I had to put this out there to see how many other players feel the same way.
Road to the Show is hands-down the gold standard for single-player sports career modes. Whether I want a realistic grind or want to crank my sliders to hit over .750 with 100+ home runs in a season, San Diego Studio seems to actually respects how players choose to play their own offline careers.
Meanwhile, over on the ice, EA has a complete monopoly on hockey, and single-player fans have nowhere else to turn. Coming back to EA's NHL series for the first time since NHL 95, the difference in offline career quality is night and day:
- Broken Career Mode Sliders: In EA's Be a Pro, "Human" gameplay sliders apply to your entire roster instead of just your player-locked skater. When I adjusted my personal sliders to build a superstar on a rebuilding team, it turned every single AI line into Hall of Famersâto the point where the entire Vancouver Canucks roster was leading the NHL in points at the same time. In Road to the Show, adjusting your batting or pitching sliders lets me play the exact career experience I want without turning every AI teammate into Babe Ruth.
- Ignored Offline Feedback: Instead of separating User Skater, AI Teammates, and CPU Opponent sliders or fixing core AI logic, EA leaves single-player flaws untouched year after year.
- No Community Creation Depth: In MLB The Show, Vaults and Create-a-Stadium/Roster tools keep the game alive forever. Even if a studio launched a hockey game without every minor league license on day one, a creation suite like SDS's would have full rosters built by the community in the first week.
For everyone else here who plays both baseball and hockey: would you buy a Road to the Show-style NHL game made by San Diego Studio on day one? Let's get a thread going so the team sees how much demand there is for real competition on the ice.
Would anyone else love a San Diego Studio hockey game? (RTTS style)
Would anyone else love a San Diego Studio hockey game? (RTTS style)
Would anyone else love a San Diego Studio hockey game? (RTTS style)