Im someone who only plays franchise and RTTS- I dont do online or diamond dynasty and all that so For me with Franchise wishlist:
-With AI and all the coding etc out there- can we get Minor league and spring training venues to start getting added into the game.
-Spring training is really bad and would be neat to have some emphasis on Spring training with your player developing there with the Cactus and Grapefruit stadiums
- Bring back the trade bar as flying blind on trades and not really knowing how close or far away is tough- As well counter trades should be more realistic- sometimes you will see computer giving up stuff to get a trade done that the system never allows yourself to do with massive trades. We should be able to include draft picks and more than 3 players and other options.
-Allow us to resign staff before season ends- this is stupid to have staff become free agents all the time and not realistic when you should be able to extend them during season if you wish.
-Would like to see the engine upgrades so were not reading comic book blurbs and instead they are talking. - Should be able to go over the cap to make a trade but then have to get back under the cap after the trade. A team in real world can make a trade that sends them over the cap and by x date need to get back under- this should be the case
- Drafting still is difficult in that majority of players drafted are crazy low rating in the 50's. Very few A or B players out there amongst the entire MLB to possibly trade as prospects. This really is representative of reality. While yes most players don't make the show, there is certainly more than 2 A rated players in a minor league system with a team. So it makes trading for prospects a little difficult in that sense.
-RTTS the agent should have more involvement with hey we need to ask for a trade to give you a better option. Or hey these teams were contenders last year to look at in Free agency, or hey this will make you highest paid player- somehwat fly blind on all of that stuff. Its hard in RTTS to pay attention to which teams are actually good and have been good so you may want to join them. Also if your waiting to see what teams are interested but have no clue so if you wait 2 days a team just pulls their offer and never shows up again. WHy not have the agent going into free agency saying hey Ive been talking to Red Sox, Angels and Rangers and they are going to make a strong push for you etc... Just more realistic thats all. Other than having to sim days to see who may offer etc.. As well should be able to lock in with a team in free agency to start negotiations back and forth. So we tell agent- Great Reds are interested thats where I want to go, make the deal happen. Probably asking too much on that front especially for blurbs haha - Overall I love MLB the Show but man this game if they really wanted to invest in it could make this extremely immersible compared to other sports games, because baseball lends itself more to the behind the scenes and development compared to other sports. Anyway as a guy who is by no means a die hard video gamer or expert like many of you- this would be my basic 2 cents of feedback for the game. Hell some of this may already be addressed and I missed it lol