This happened to me last night, wait for the timer to go to 0. After the forfeit doesn’t work and you are on the paused screen with 0 time and 3:15 of your own time, go to your bullpen warm someone up and then put him in the game. Then turn off your controller, and turn it back on. Put me right back into the game with my new relief pitcher. Gave him the loss because he probably walked away…. Loser. Hope this helps someone in the future.

Alan Incrane_XBL
@Alan Incrane_XBL