90 Luis Robert vs 89 Jarred Kelenic

[skk0513]

Thinking about one of these at CF. Who you got? I need one more prospect to get 90 Mackenzie Gore from collections and could use a CF so figured I could make one of these work.

[fletchtait_PSN]

Jarred Kelenic is far better and a lefty. He raked for me and Robert didn’t

[onnagood1_PSN]

@fletchtait said in 90 Luis Robert vs 89 Jarred Kelenic:

Jarred Kelenic is far better and a lefty. He raked for me and Robert didn’t

I respectfully disagree.

Used Kelenic for 8 games before deciding to get rid of him for Robert. Kelenic hit only .190 avg in those 8 games, while Robert in 14 games is hitting .308 avg 3 HR, and despite inferior attributes, hit all three against right handed pitchers. Robert was obviously the far better choice.

Based on both of our experiences, it just comes down to who you happen to play better with. So you'll just have to try out both and make your own decision.

[Nard_Dawg_58_PSN]

It’s a toss up for me. I’ve had mixed results with them, both super streaky. I used kelenic for a while and only hit around .180 with him, then switched to Robert and hit .310 with him with around 10 HR (until I got Juan Pierre lol) but for the event I have them both in my lineup, and since then, Robert’s average has dropped all the way down to .230 and kelenics has climbed all the way to ≈.290 with 6 HR. I’d say try them both out and see who works out best for you.