Finest Reveals from X/Twitter users
-
@NotesOfJohn_MLBTS
We did get Sean Newcomb, Gavin Williams and Garrett Whitlock so I don't think this is a big issue -
@Talkingben9558_XBL We did, but personally i'd like more fresh cards rather than fourth and fifth iterations of the same guys.
-
@NotesOfJohn_MLBTS said in Finest Reveals from X/Twitter users:
I was hoping we'd get more Finest cards for guys who didn't get much love during the year.
I know the concept and i know their hands are tied sometimes, but personally i don't need another Tarik Skubal or Kyle Stowers.
There is still a program coming. They have been giving us more cards lately so I am cautiously optimistic with it. Also could be a pack coming too.
-
Gosh darn so many loaded OF but PCA is a must

-
Is Paul Skenes going to get a Finest card?
-
@brainfreeze442_PSN said in Finest Reveals from X/Twitter users:
Is Paul Skenes going to get a Finest card?
It possible, probably even likely. There is a Finest program next week and they have been releasing them as rewards in other modes.
-
True, appreciate the feedback and all the knowledge you drop on here.
I hope you don’t mind, but while I have the chance I have a quick question. What is considered my MLB the Show username? I did just post this in a different section, but if you know and don’t mind answering when you see this that would be helpful.
Thanks
-
I helped reveal Angels #FINEST2025 in @MLBTHESHOW https://mlbthe.show/finest2025
-
All these cards look great. But without a Team Affinity program, it’s just such a letdown. Please give us more than the voucher exchange. I miss when TA was big program paths, conquests and missions encouraging us to build our rosters and play the game. This is the earliest I’ve run out of things to do since I started playing in 2021
-
@Dolenz_PSN said in Finest Reveals from X/Twitter users:
The way I read Colin's response earlier was that there is a chase pack you get for inputting the code. The community rewards that show on the top of the finest page are for the community and will appear in the store (unspecified as to when).
I find their emails to be spotty at best. I still have emails for the last few scouting reports. I got an email about last week's live stream but the last time I checked nothing today yet
Cut off to redeem codes is Tuesday. Chase Pack will be delivered on Wednesday 11/12. Details here, https://theshow.com/news/the-2025-finest-series-returns-in-mlb-the-show-25/
The 85+ Diamond Choice Pack, Finest Choice Pack and Extreme Voucher (if unlocked) will all be available in the Show Shop. Stay tuned for more details.
We are sending out codes by division based on your team selected on booting the game. There are scenarios where that team isn't available and we randomly assign a team.
-
@Teak2112_MLBTS Hope you're right, mate.
-
Sonny Gray having one of his worst seasons get a finest card is wild. Good win loss record though
-
@virusts_XBL said in Finest Reveals from X/Twitter users:
Sonny Gray having one of his worst seasons get a finest card is wild. Good win loss record though
His era wasn't good but he did have 200Ks with only 38 walks and a good record. If you just ignore the ERA and look at everything else he is worthy.
Theyve also given a lot of the other options cards already, like Svanson. Leahy would have been a reasonable option assuming pitcher was intentional for captain purposes
-
@NotesOfJohn_MLBTS said in Finest Reveals from X/Twitter users:
@Teak2112_MLBTS Hope you're right, mate.
Put it this way, 2 of the three cover athletes have gotten a recent 99. Skenes is by far the best of the three. He is getting a juiced card still.
-
@virusts_XBL said in Finest Reveals from X/Twitter users:
Sonny Gray having one of his worst seasons get a finest card is wild. Good win loss record though
I assume that they are trying to give the 5 teams without a pitcher captain a pitcher captain finally. Actually I still only have the live version of Sonny because his Summer card was a Diamond Quest reward and the price of that card has never come down and I refused to pay 50K in stubs for a 93 overall
I just hope that this is not our only finest because the players who probably deserved it like Contreras, Burleson or even Winn. If not it will be somewhat disappointing
-
What about an extreme voucher?
-
Community award tier for the finest releases. The last tier has an “extreme voucher”
-
Surely Yankees is Cody right? and also my email hasn't came in at all, ANDDDD I'm assuming the extreme voucher would be for the Extreme Program right?
-
@Dolenz_PSN id rather have a masyn winn finest, absolute stud
-
we absolutley have to get a Masyn Winn finest.