BR Should Be On HOF
-
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@coastereight said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@ImDFC said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I'm not saying you're wrong. I just can't play HoF online. the PCI is too small for me to use with an analog stick. Kudos to you fellas who can, but I making precise movements is just not something these thumbs were built for. Now if I had some sort of twin stick controller...
What they mean is that they would be able to win easier in BR if it were on HoF. It makes it harder for people with less reaction time. That is all they care about. Same discussion every year and these guys have to same old argument. I personally do not care either way, but them saying the game plays better on HoF just means it plays better for them on HoF. They are not looking out for the community like they want you to believe. They just cant say, "Make BR HoF so that I can win more often." Does not sound as nice. They HATE the fact that they can lose on All Star and that it gives other people with slower reflexes a chance.
Despite your hate for the premise, a smaller pci makes for less inconsistency in results, hence the “game plays better on hall of fame” comments, if BR is going to give out to give out the best rewards then yes worse players should have less of a chance to win.
Less inconsistency in results? That is the same thing as you losing less often. Just say, "ya, he is right, I would win more".
So just so I’m clear, your argument for the game mode that gives out the best rewards is that there should be more inconsistency in your results? Just want to make sure I’m reading it right
I do not think of it in those terms. Those are your words trying to explain away that you want a higher chance to win.
Don't you want it on All Star so you or others have a higher chance to win?
Also, I've explained it's not just that. It plays better because there is less randomness, high fastballs are useable, and strikeouts happen at more realistic rates.
I’ve always found his way of thinking to be funny, based on his comments I’ve always made the assumption that he was an older guy, but for an older guy his comments never seem to make sense, they’re the generation that’s always pounding home “kids are so soft with their participation trophy upbringing” but then he’s always banging the drum for participation trophies here and maybe I’m wrong on him being an older guy but i don’t think I am.
Personal attacks are not allowed on these forums.
There is no personal attack there, unless being old is a personal attack which if it is I’d be attacking myself as well
-
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@ImDFC said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I'm not saying you're wrong. I just can't play HoF online. the PCI is too small for me to use with an analog stick. Kudos to you fellas who can, but I making precise movements is just not something these thumbs were built for. Now if I had some sort of twin stick controller...
What they mean is that they would be able to win easier in BR if it were on HoF. It makes it harder for people with less reaction time. That is all they care about. Same discussion every year and these guys have to same old argument. I personally do not care either way, but them saying the game plays better on HoF just means it plays better for them on HoF. They are not looking out for the community like they want you to believe. They just cant say, "Make BR HoF so that I can win more often." Does not sound as nice. They HATE the fact that they can lose on All Star and that it gives other people with slower reflexes a chance.
People with slower reflexes shouldn't be rewarded for having slower reflexes. If someone can react a little quicker and more accurately they should be rewarded more.
Just the disclaimer: I will never go 12-0 in BR, I'll be lucky to get 6 wins in BR. -
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
-
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
I swear AS divisions in RS are playing on the offline HOF settings, pitch speeds and PCI size seem identical.
-
@foge011 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@ImDFC said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I'm not saying you're wrong. I just can't play HoF online. the PCI is too small for me to use with an analog stick. Kudos to you fellas who can, but I making precise movements is just not something these thumbs were built for. Now if I had some sort of twin stick controller...
What they mean is that they would be able to win easier in BR if it were on HoF. It makes it harder for people with less reaction time. That is all they care about. Same discussion every year and these guys have to same old argument. I personally do not care either way, but them saying the game plays better on HoF just means it plays better for them on HoF. They are not looking out for the community like they want you to believe. They just cant say, "Make BR HoF so that I can win more often." Does not sound as nice. They HATE the fact that they can lose on All Star and that it gives other people with slower reflexes a chance.
People with slower reflexes shouldn't be rewarded for having slower reflexes. If someone can react a little quicker and more accurately they should be rewarded more.
That is true. That is not my argument. My argument is them trying to convince people with lesser reflexes that HoF is better for them because it plays better. That is not the reason for their argument. It is to win more often with less challenge for themselves. So I agree that they should make it Legend so there is no one playing who is not a "greater player".
-
@JEEZY-E said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
I swear AS divisions in RS are playing on the offline HOF settings, pitch speeds and PCI size seem identical.
One of the issues last year was that AS was so random and wild. The pcis were huge and it was pretty much just toss up games to who can hit more homeruns
-
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
But the problem right now is that saying that, for some people, means that you’re trying to be an elitist douche that’s not “looking out for the best of the community”
-
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
But the problem right now is that saying that, for some people, means that you’re trying to be an elitist douche that’s not “looking out for the best of the community”
I am in no way shape or form, elite. Im competitive at minimum but im just lucky to have seen how hof plays in this game. Its more of a suggestion to people in the community, like play the event now while its on hof. Even if your team is not “stacked” the experience is definitely more fluent and rewarding. People can say whatever they feel. Im just saying “hey, go check it out”
-
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@foge011 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@Vipersneak said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@ImDFC said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I'm not saying you're wrong. I just can't play HoF online. the PCI is too small for me to use with an analog stick. Kudos to you fellas who can, but I making precise movements is just not something these thumbs were built for. Now if I had some sort of twin stick controller...
What they mean is that they would be able to win easier in BR if it were on HoF. It makes it harder for people with less reaction time. That is all they care about. Same discussion every year and these guys have to same old argument. I personally do not care either way, but them saying the game plays better on HoF just means it plays better for them on HoF. They are not looking out for the community like they want you to believe. They just cant say, "Make BR HoF so that I can win more often." Does not sound as nice. They HATE the fact that they can lose on All Star and that it gives other people with slower reflexes a chance.
People with slower reflexes shouldn't be rewarded for having slower reflexes. If someone can react a little quicker and more accurately they should be rewarded more.
That is true. That is not my argument. My argument is them trying to convince people with lesser reflexes that HoF is better for them because it plays better. That is not the reason for their argument. It is to win more often with less challenge for themselves. So I agree that they should make it Legend so there is no one playing who is not a "greater player".
That's not the last line of your previous post. You said "it gives other people with slower reflexes a chance". Honestly, if you are slower to react you should not be able to have a chance with someone that is quicker and more accurate.
-
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@JEEZY-E said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
I swear AS divisions in RS are playing on the offline HOF settings, pitch speeds and PCI size seem identical.
One of the issues last year was that AS was so random and wild. The pcis were huge and it was pretty much just toss up games to who can hit more homeruns
I know AS was a hell hole last year, I was stuck in it for the majority of the year. But if this year the AS divisions are already playing on the offline HOF settings, people aren't going to enjoy the HOF division's, they are already complaining about pitch speeds. I haven't reached the HOF difficulties yet, but I imagine for someone like myself it wouldn't be enjoyable, and I am someone who exclusively plays HOF and Legend offline.
-
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
But the problem right now is that saying that, for some people, means that you’re trying to be an elitist douche that’s not “looking out for the best of the community”
I am in no way shape or form, elite. Im competitive at minimum but im just lucky to have seen how hof plays in this game. Its more of a suggestion to people in the community, like play the event now while its on hof. Even if your team is not “stacked” the experience is definitely more fluent and rewarding. People can say whatever they feel. Im just saying “hey, go check it out”
That is fair. But I think people do check it out for the most part. You put that in a very good way, and in your case you are trying to help others.
-
I agree. I love HOF. It’s balanced. Not dumb at all.
-
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@coastereight said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@MrGamebred said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I love this game on HOF. All-Star always has and always will be a joke.
HOF is almost perfect right now. I think they tweaked pitch speeds in one of the patches again because it's just about perfect. You can get blown away by a high fastball, but only if your opponent sets it up. The pci being smaller is so much better. Sure, you might strikeout more but when you do hit it well you're more likely to get rewarded. It's just so much better. They still have the fielding bugs and what not but HOF solves a lot of issues.
A sensible take, that is quite true. There’s a lot of yelling of “this game is trash on this forum,” but I really enjoy the game on hall of fame
I been saying for the last 2 years that HOF should be the difficulty for most of online matchups. If you’re not good enough, practice and get better. Last year and this year,HOF is the best difficulty imo
-
@DaShrimpP1mp said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@coastereight said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@MrGamebred said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I love this game on HOF. All-Star always has and always will be a joke.
HOF is almost perfect right now. I think they tweaked pitch speeds in one of the patches again because it's just about perfect. You can get blown away by a high fastball, but only if your opponent sets it up. The pci being smaller is so much better. Sure, you might strikeout more but when you do hit it well you're more likely to get rewarded. It's just so much better. They still have the fielding bugs and what not but HOF solves a lot of issues.
A sensible take, that is quite true. There’s a lot of yelling of “this game is trash on this forum,” but I really enjoy the game on hall of fame
I been saying for the last 2 years that HOF should be the difficulty for most of online matchups. If you’re not good enough, practice and get better. Last year and this year,HOF is the best difficulty imo
I agree, someone on here 2 nights ago was talking about how the game was absolute trash etc. He got to hall of fame and did a complete 180 on it
-
@DaShrimpP1mp said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@coastereight said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@MrGamebred said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I love this game on HOF. All-Star always has and always will be a joke.
HOF is almost perfect right now. I think they tweaked pitch speeds in one of the patches again because it's just about perfect. You can get blown away by a high fastball, but only if your opponent sets it up. The pci being smaller is so much better. Sure, you might strikeout more but when you do hit it well you're more likely to get rewarded. It's just so much better. They still have the fielding bugs and what not but HOF solves a lot of issues.
A sensible take, that is quite true. There’s a lot of yelling of “this game is trash on this forum,” but I really enjoy the game on hall of fame
I been saying for the last 2 years that HOF should be the difficulty for most of online matchups. If you’re not good enough, practice and get better. Last year and this year,HOF is the best difficulty imo
So essentially you want DD to just be for a select few, some people don't have time to practice, they have things like jobs and families. Limiting who can and wants to use your product is not a good business practice.
-
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@DaShrimpP1mp said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@coastereight said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@MrGamebred said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I love this game on HOF. All-Star always has and always will be a joke.
HOF is almost perfect right now. I think they tweaked pitch speeds in one of the patches again because it's just about perfect. You can get blown away by a high fastball, but only if your opponent sets it up. The pci being smaller is so much better. Sure, you might strikeout more but when you do hit it well you're more likely to get rewarded. It's just so much better. They still have the fielding bugs and what not but HOF solves a lot of issues.
A sensible take, that is quite true. There’s a lot of yelling of “this game is trash on this forum,” but I really enjoy the game on hall of fame
I been saying for the last 2 years that HOF should be the difficulty for most of online matchups. If you’re not good enough, practice and get better. Last year and this year,HOF is the best difficulty imo
I agree, someone on here 2 nights ago was talking about how the game was absolute trash etc. He got to hall of fame and did a complete 180 on it
I was very similar. All-star sucks even more this year with the way pitching has been. Now I’m stuck in legend and it’s kind of meh. I feel like hitting is near perfect rewarding in HOF, but legend isn’t the same. Granted, I see a lot of kluber, so until we see more hitters who can compete with his attributes I’ll hold my judgment on it.
I like strikeouts. It’s way more realistic, especially in this era of baseball. -
Just to play devil's advocate, striking out 27 times wouldn't be super fun.
I havent played on HoF this year yet, but it was a struggle last year for me. I agree it plays better with a smaller pci, assuming you gave the reflexes to handle it. Unfortunately some people dont.
I wouldn't get upset if BR was on HoF, but it would be nice if there was a mode that stuck to All Star as well, either events or something else.
-
I've played a couple of games on HOF for the event. Its probably the most enjoyable difficulty in the past couple of games
-
@JEEZY-E said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@JEEZY-E said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@skepple15 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
@InTh3iLLCity41 said in BR Should Be On HOF:
I also suggest them making hof a season early in RS in WC
100% agreed
I dont think enough people have experienced and saw that hof plays so much better and fluently than any other difficulty, otherwise i think there would be more in favor of so.
I swear AS divisions in RS are playing on the offline HOF settings, pitch speeds and PCI size seem identical.
One of the issues last year was that AS was so random and wild. The pcis were huge and it was pretty much just toss up games to who can hit more homeruns
I know AS was a hell hole last year, I was stuck in it for the majority of the year. But if this year the AS divisions are already playing on the offline HOF settings, people aren't going to enjoy the HOF division's, they are already complaining about pitch speeds. I haven't reached the HOF difficulties yet, but I imagine for someone like myself it wouldn't be enjoyable, and I am someone who exclusively plays HOF and Legend offline.
I honestly don't think the speeds are that much different anymore. The big difference is the pci size being smaller, which allows both the hitter and pitcher to be rewarded more fairly and consistently.
-
Everyone who is skeptical and never played HOF online should play the event right now and use hitters with decent vision. I really think people would like it.
