Win trading ban
-
@CHOMBONDO_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Dolenz_PSN said in Win trading ban:
That is the banned user's team (The Eagles) showing as CPU but the other team has a username attached to it. So it was either an online game of some kind or a mini seasons game. I thought mini season games showed the mini seasons team names (like the Whales) in the game log. I have not played Mini seasons yet but I did not recognize either the Tigers or Dash as a mini season team.
I'm curious now. I will start a mini season tomorrow so I can see how it is listed in the game logs.
Look mine up, I've played tons of miniseasons and have no idea how you looked that up lol.
Here is a mini-season game from your game logs.
https://mlb23.theshow.com/games/37579492?username=CHOMBONDO
It shows CPU as the team name and the user on the line score but has the team name Kaiju listed in the box score with the lineup.
It also does not say 2023 online game in the summary at the bottom
-
@Touchemall44_PSN said in Win trading ban:
I got the ban too. Mine is for win sharing on BR. I have not played one BR game this year. I have played one RS game.
Your game logs show multiple online games that ended in 0-0 scores. Here is an example.
https://mlb23.theshow.com/games/18903243?username=Touchemall44
I am not saying that the logs are right or wrong but games like that one have to be red flags for SDS.
-
@Dolenz_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Touchemall44_PSN said in Win trading ban:
I got the ban too. Mine is for win sharing on BR. I have not played one BR game this year. I have played one RS game.
Your game logs show multiple online games that ended in 0-0 scores. Here is an example.
https://mlb23.theshow.com/games/18903243?username=Touchemall44
I am not saying that the logs are right or wrong but games like that one have to be red flags for SDS.
-
I only see one game? Where do I find the rest?
-
I have never had that lineup. Like ever. Could someone possibly have logged in to my account?
-
-
@Dolenz_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Touchemall44_PSN said in Win trading ban:
I got the ban too. Mine is for win sharing on BR. I have not played one BR game this year. I have played one RS game.
Your game logs show multiple online games that ended in 0-0 scores. Here is an example.
https://mlb23.theshow.com/games/18903243?username=Touchemall44
I am not saying that the logs are right or wrong but games like that one have to be red flags for SDS.
Dude…Wow…I just saw my entire game log. I see the games I played against the computer. I also see a lot of 0-0 games as you stated against other real ppl. I 100% did not compete in those games. Is there anyway that they could have possibly played my team in some other game mode? I know there was a way to last year, where your team would play against other people even while you were offline. That would be only explanation. No way did I play in some of those games. This is getting more and more ridiculous.
-
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
-
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
-
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
For the Franchise part, MTO counts as franchise on ones profile I believe, but yeah you are right on that other stuff
-
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
Nope no linked accounts for me
-
@the_dragon1912 said in Win trading ban:
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
For the Franchise part, MTO counts as franchise on ones profile I believe, but yeah you are right on that other stuff
I have played MTO but not to the tune of 2 hours
-
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
I looked up someone's Mini Season game last night. That game showed the mini seasons fake team name on the Box score, did not show a user name for the other team, and did not list the game as a 2023 online game.
-
@Dolenz_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
I looked up someone's Mini Season game last night. That game showed the mini seasons fake team name on the Box score, did not show a user name for the other team, and did not list the game as a 2023 online game.
Yeah. Same here. I also talked to someone on twitter who got banned. Two days ago SDS lifted their ban and apologized. I’m hoping that we all get the same treatment. I highly doubt that those affected and on here looking for answers would waste our time if we knew we were guilty.
-
@Touchemall44_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Dolenz_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
I looked up someone's Mini Season game last night. That game showed the mini seasons fake team name on the Box score, did not show a user name for the other team, and did not list the game as a 2023 online game.
Yeah. Same here. I also talked to someone on twitter who got banned. Two days ago SDS lifted their ban and apologized. I’m hoping that we all get the same treatment. I highly doubt that those affected and on here looking for answers would waste our time if we knew we were guilty.
That's exactly what guilty people would do, of course I'm not saying you are, but the world is full of guilty people who claim Innocence
-
@eatyum_PSN said in Win trading ban:
That's exactly what guilty people would do, of course I'm not saying you are, but the world is full of guilty people who claim Innocence
If you look at my game log you will see all games v CPU. There is a strange user name that played a game, and no clue who this person is, and lost v. CPU on rookie, so this didn't help me out whatsoever. I wish a human would interact with people who are suffering this ordeal and not just send out bot responses.
-
@eatyum_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Touchemall44_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Dolenz_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
I looked up someone's Mini Season game last night. That game showed the mini seasons fake team name on the Box score, did not show a user name for the other team, and did not list the game as a 2023 online game.
Yeah. Same here. I also talked to someone on twitter who got banned. Two days ago SDS lifted their ban and apologized. I’m hoping that we all get the same treatment. I highly doubt that those affected and on here looking for answers would waste our time if we knew we were guilty.
That's exactly what guilty people would do, of course I'm not saying you are, but the world is full of guilty people who claim Innocence
One look at my game log will tell them everything they need to know.
-
I went back and looked at Reddit from last year in regards to Bans. It looks like 5-9 days was the turn around time to lift bans if they were lifted at all. So I guess we shall see. I look at the two year ban as weird. Like does Sony/SDS not want the money from next years game? I don't have a business degree but feel a company would want to make money off users. Madden has been banking on this for years with the same [censored] game.
-
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I went back and looked at Reddit from last year in regards to Bans. It looks like 5-9 days was the turn around time to lift bans if they were lifted at all. So I guess we shall see. I look at the two year ban as weird. Like does Sony/SDS not want the money from next years game? I don't have a business degree but feel a company would want to make money off users. Madden has been banking on this for years with the same [censored] game.
Also, trying to find a human to interact with is asinine. There should be some sort of chat or something.
-
@Touchemall44_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Dolenz_PSN said in Win trading ban:
@Pennstatefencer_MLBTS said in Win trading ban:
@NashBoxTwenty_XBL said in Win trading ban:
I just looked over my game logs and info. The Show.com says I have played 2 and a half hours of Franchise. I haven't even gotten past the choose your team screen in that mode. In addition I have 8 games that show a 0-0 score with no pitches being thrown. 2 of those were Mini Seasons restarts. 5 of the remaining games with a 0-0 score were games played while I was on a Bahamas Cruise ship. Wonder how I logged in for those games??
In the past I think mini season, and before that extra innings games would show up in your game log when other real players would go up against your team. I wonder if that is the issue here. Still wouldn't explain Franchise though. Do you have a linked account (Xbox to Switch or Playstation)?
I looked up someone's Mini Season game last night. That game showed the mini seasons fake team name on the Box score, did not show a user name for the other team, and did not list the game as a 2023 online game.
Yeah. Same here. I also talked to someone on twitter who got banned. Two days ago SDS lifted their ban and apologized. I’m hoping that we all get the same treatment. I highly doubt that those affected and on here looking for answers would waste our time if we knew we were guilty.
Same here. I spoke to someone who was banned for the same reason and they got a response to their ticket saying that there was a bug with mini seasons that made them appear as online against another user if it used their lineup as the opponent. But my issue is, why did one get resolved and the rest of us can’t even get an answer -
ive noticed the game is attaching username to cpu game so this is probably the culprit. my history shows I played people ive never played when I was doing mini seasons.
-
Looks like I’ll stay away from Mini Seasons for a bit. Started two games vs CPU this morning and quit bc I was messing with my custom uniforms since they fixed the glitch.
-
So I looked at all my 0-0 games in my play log. EVERY single game with a 0-0 score involved a player who went 12-0 without throwing a pitch! One of them had 16 wins in a row with 0 pitches thrown. One player had 14 game sin a row against the same team. So I'm guessing that maybe if we "played them" then we are attached to them. That doesn't explain how they matched up with my team. One game happened while I was at work, one while i was at the movies, and 5 games when i was out of the country.
