New legends for 23
-
Bumping this thread as we will start seeing confirmed new legends. First one is Jeter. For some reason a polarizing player. It’s not like Logan Paul was added to the game people.
-
Julio Lugo and John Rocker
-
Adrian beltre and Juan Gonzalez
-
@SakAttack87_PSN said in New legends for 23:
Norm Charlton would be a nice lefty addition for the bullpen.
With Jose Rijo and Randy Myers....Have Jose pitch through 7, Norm in the 7th, Dibble in the 8th, then Randy to close it. Nasty!
-
@xElRojo44x_MLBTS said in New legends for 23:
@SakAttack87_PSN said in New legends for 23:
Norm Charlton would be a nice lefty addition for the bullpen.
With Jose Rijo and Randy Myers....Have Jose pitch through 7, Norm in the 7th, Dibble in the 8th, then Randy to close it. Nasty!
It’s crazy how the Reds and the Pirates have some of the best all time lineups in the Show but neither has great pitching. I would love the addition of the other Nasty Boys and Rijo.
I won’t edit but I forgot that they have Cueto, Greene and Seaver with Chapman and Dibble in the pen. Completely disregard. The Pirates definitely have no pitch though ;). Sorry @arvcpa_MLBTS
-
Carlos Gonzalez (the diamond fielding LF card from a few years ago).
Jose Reyes
Adrian Beltre
Tony Pena
Darryl Strawberry
Dwight Gooden
Sandy Koufax
Jose Rijo
Albert Belle
Alex Gordon -
Omar Vizquel.
Manny Ramirez.
Zito.
Sosa.
Clemens.
Pettit. -
Lance berkman, Tim Lincecum, Eric Chavez, and Barry bonds.
-
@Ericulous1_PSN said in New legends for 23:
The Pirates definitely have no pitch though
Yes we do! They're just all on other teams (Cole, Musgrove, etc, etc, etc)
-
Tim Tebow
-
@Ericulous1_PSN said in New legends for 23:
Bumping this thread as we will start seeing confirmed new legends. First one is Jeter. For some reason a polarizing player. It’s not like Logan Paul was added to the game people.
Logan Paul will have a card soon enough. They lost me when they gave everybody Babe Ruth attributes.
Jeter was great, but half of that was his longevity. He wasn't the best at anything I don't think. Slow and steady wins the race tho.
They're going to have to juice his card so crazy to compete with the soon to be Ha- Seoung Kim April Topps Now card.
-
@arvcpa_MLBTS said in New legends for 23:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in New legends for 23:
The Pirates definitely have no pitch though
Yes we do! They're just all on other teams (Cole, Musgrove, etc, etc, etc)
You had a pitcher in the mid 60’s that threw gas. Bob Veale. He was on a bad Pirates team despite having Clemente, Maz and Stargell
-
@CCARR77_PSN said in New legends for 23:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in New legends for 23:
Bumping this thread as we will start seeing confirmed new legends. First one is Jeter. For some reason a polarizing player. It’s not like Logan Paul was added to the game people.
Logan Paul will have a card soon enough. They lost me when they gave everybody Babe Ruth attributes.
Jeter was great, but half of that was his longevity. He wasn't the best at anything I don't think. Slow and steady wins the race tho.
They're going to have to juice his card so crazy to compete with the soon to be Ha- Seoung Kim April Topps Now card.
Haha, are you a Kim fan? He’s a total fan favorite in SD? Hope he breaks through this year. And yes, I agree, Jeter was not the best at anything, just great. I do not think he is one of the inner circle HOFers but I do think he’s much better than many give him credit for. It’s become trendy to say he’s overrated.
-
Guys … the captain‘s pack is a hint for some new guys … Try and search for names here —> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Captain_(baseball)
Jason Varitek was a captain e.g.
-
Modern Legends:
- Ichiro Suzuki
- Carlos Beltran
- Ken Caminiti
- Aramis Ramirez
- Magglio Ordonez
- A.J. Pierzynski
- Dwight Gooden
- Carlton Fisk
- Mark Buehrle
- Mark Grace
- Ben Zobrist
- Tim Lincecum
- Barry Zito
- Sammy Sosa
- David Wright
- Manny Ramirez
- Kevin Brown
- Bo Jackson
- Steve Carlton
- Alex Rodriguez
- Barry Bonds
- Scott Rolen
- Mark McGwire
Old-Timers
- Roger Maris
- Frank Robinson
- Carl Yastrzemski
- Eddie Collins
- Tris Speaker
- Rogers Hornsby
- Ted Williams
- Sandy Koufax
- Ed Walsh
- Joe DiMaggio
- Ty Cobb
I'll think of more, I'm sure.
-
I just want a high 90’s Cecil Fielder once before I die
-
@Ericulous1_PSN said in New legends for 23:
Modern Legends-
- Lance Berkman
- Scott Rolen
- Carlos Beltran
- Chris Carpenter
- Andy Pettite
- Jeff Kent
- Ichiro Suzuki
- Adrian Beltre
- K-Rod
- Javy Lopez
- Bernie Williams
- Matt Williams
- Albert Belle
- Bobby Bonilla
- Tim Lincecum
Old Timer Legends-
- Rogers Hornsby
- Dizzy Dean
3.Tony Oliva - Boog Powell
- George Foster (bring him back)
- Roy Campanella
- Roger Maris
- Lou Whitaker
- Josh Gibson
- Maury Wills
- Sandy Koufax
- Luis Tiant
Like this list. Bringing Hornsby back would be great. Another legend I want to see is Joe DiMaggio. I know, another Yankees player; but he was one of the best players in an era of great players.
-
@brainfreeze442 said in New legends for 23:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in New legends for 23:
Modern Legends-
- Lance Berkman
- Scott Rolen
- Carlos Beltran
- Chris Carpenter
- Andy Pettite
- Jeff Kent
- Ichiro Suzuki
- Adrian Beltre
- K-Rod
- Javy Lopez
- Bernie Williams
- Matt Williams
- Albert Belle
- Bobby Bonilla
- Tim Lincecum
Old Timer Legends-
- Rogers Hornsby
- Dizzy Dean
3.Tony Oliva - Boog Powell
- George Foster (bring him back)
- Roy Campanella
- Roger Maris
- Lou Whitaker
- Josh Gibson
- Maury Wills
- Sandy Koufax
- Luis Tiant
Like this list. Bringing Hornsby back would be great. Another legend I want to see is Joe DiMaggio. I know, another Yankees player; but he was one of the best players in an era of great players.
Even though there are so many Yankees I’m sure everyone would be happy with DiMaggio. I’d love a retro finest 1960 or 1961 Roger Maris speaking of the Yankees. Or a perfect game Don Larsen
-
Jeter is such a big addition for the franchise, but if we could add just one more legend from the Yankees can we please get Bernie Williams. There would be no complaints from me if we saw someone like DiMaggio or maybe Andy Pettitte. However, Bernie was my favorite as a kid and his best card would probably find itself at the top of many lineups.
Cecil Fielder. I know he's a one-dimensional player being a power-hitting first basemen, but he would be a great addition especially with Prince back in the game. You hit a no doubter with him and even your opponent will replay it.
The game could use more dominant left-handed starters and I think that Johan Santana would be a solid option with his stuff and overall pitch mix. People forget how dominant that guy was in his prime during the mid 2000s.
On that note, give me David Wells too just because he was a big personality and had a rubber arm.
Jose Reyes would be a popular card because he was a switch-hitter with great speed and a really compact swing.
A great Kevin Brown card would probably wind up on most endgame rotations. His stuff was so nasty with that heavy sinker which we know is still the most effective pitch in the game.
Norm Charlton/Randy Myers/Sparky Lyle/Jesse Orosco would all be welcome additions as there still aren't enough quality lefty relievers in the game.
People may argue, but with Cishek and O'Day retiring they will most likely not be in the game anymore which creates a pretty big void when it comes to bullpen options with a funky delivery. The two pitchers that I would love to see added would be Jeff Nelson and Dan Quisenberry. Cheap or not, that sidearm/submarine release slinging frisbee sliders would make them good pen options when you need something fancier than an outlier fastball. Maybe go the Moneyball route even with Chad Bradford.
Carlos Gonzalez isn't a favorite, but I had a small sample size with him back in The Show 20 - my first baseball videogame in over a decade - and he had one of the best swings ever. The only issue was that they released his best card in like January so the game was pretty dead by then and he hasn't been back since.
Nomar Garciaparra is probably a top want for a lot of Boston fans outside of Manny Ramirez. His prime was cut short, but he was the face of that organization for a while and I would honestly just love to see his batting stance in the game.
Speaking of the Red Sox, if this "Captain's Choice" pack for the upcoming game will be featuring cards for players who were captain of their team, then Jason Varitek would be a great addition.
David Wright is another that would be a perfect fit for this program/collection especially after he wasn't included this past year with them bringing back almost all of the previous cover athletes.
I said that I was done with requests for the Yankees, but if the focus is on former captains then Thurman Munson has to be discussed.
A prime Darryl Strawberry card would probably be irreplaceable in my outfield. I would love to see one of the sweetest swings ever finally in the game.
Juan Gonzalez was one of the most feared hitters in the 1990s, but is seemingly forgotten by many when discussing the power bats of his era. Griffey was still the king growing up for my generation, but all the cool kids in peewee were replicating that Juan Gonzalez batting stance. He would be a monster in the game for sure.
At this point I can admit to just being a sucker for a unique batting stance so let's throw in Chuck Knoblauch for fun. His style was so odd that when it comes to how it would translate to The Show, he would either have one of the best glitchy swings in the game or the outright worst with absolutely no in-between.
-
A good dustin pedroia card and Carlton Fisk would be awesome
