All things equal, who are you picking between the two of them? I have tons of pros and cons for each, but I cannot decide. Tell me which player is better
Posey or Reggie Jackson
Reggie is batting .438 online with over 150 plate appearances. Absolute stud and defense isn’t all that bad
If you likeed Ted Williams last year you'll like Reggie.
If you preferred Bench or Pudge last year to Piazza you'll like Posey.
Honestly OF will always have the most depth of any position in game, Reggie will be skipped over plenty of times as the weeks and months go by. Posey can hold it down at Catcher for a really long time. I'm going with Posey even tho I know Reggie's bat is great. I know I can find other goons at OF easily.
Had the same dilemma... First game with Reggie, hit a no doubter... But hasn't hit much since... 2 for 11...but he hits the ball hard.. His defence, which I was worried about isn't too bad.. I hit well with Sanchez at catcher.
For your own personal enjoyment, I would advise that you take Reggie so that you'll have time to use him before better options become available...whereas Posey will be relevant all year. If you take Posey now, chances are by the time you get to Gold 1 there will already be better players available than Reggie, and you'll miss out on using him.