Sig Chapman or Sig Wagner

SDS

Both are around 500K. If I get to the 100pts in the BR program I was taking Chapman.

But I could always sell him and buy Wagner.

To those who have both, any reviews?

Again, I know it's based on how someone plays with that card. And I'm mainly offline right now; but I may dive into some RS after I get caught up with the offline content.

SDS

Wagner is lights out, great velo, terrific arm angle.

Chapman is the one expensive end game player I don't have (he's next).

SDS

I have both and Wagner has been far more productive for me. I audition closers as late inning set up men; Wagner has been better so, he’s my next closer-in-waiting after I P5 Hoffman.

SDS

@ericulous1_psn said in Sig Chapman or Sig Wagner:

Wagner is lights out, great velo, terrific arm angle.

Chapman is the one expensive end game player I don't have (he's next).

I like Jansen and finest Treinen better than all of them but Wagner is a close 2nd.

Chapman is good but you can get Jansen and Miller for the same price.

Jansen / Treinen
Wagner
Miller
Chapman

SDS

Also, am I the only one that usually uses relief pitchers over starters when playing full games?

After about 3 or 4 innings, pinch hitter and bring in the next out of the bullpen. I started doing this a couple of weeks ago and really enjoy the increased variety.

SDS

Aroldis because I personally prefer his pitch mix to Wagner's.

Interestingly though I'm much better in BR with Silver Wagner vs. Silver Aroldis (who has a limited repertoire).

SDS

@donttuchmethaar_xbl said in Sig Chapman or Sig Wagner:

@ericulous1_psn said in Sig Chapman or Sig Wagner:

Wagner is lights out, great velo, terrific arm angle.

Chapman is the one expensive end game player I don't have (he's next).

I like Jansen and finest Treinen better than all of them but Wagner is a close 2nd.

Chapman is good but you can get Jansen and Miller for the same price.

Jansen / Treinen
Wagner
Miller
Chapman

I already have Miller. Looking for another lefty. I like having at least three lefties in my BP.

SDS

@dbub_psn said in Sig Chapman or Sig Wagner:

Aroldis because I personally prefer his pitch mix to Wagner's.

Interestingly though I'm much better in BR with Silver Wagner vs. Silver Aroldis (who has a limited repertoire).

Ironically, I feel the same way about Chapman. I'd rather have a relief pitcher, or closer, that has 5 pitches than one with 3-4 pitches.

Thus why I was leaning towards Chapman.

SDS

I got em both pretty even for me.