How do I give the pitcher RTTS fielding controls, as in O to first, Triangle to second, Square to third, X to home? I've gone through every single setting and cannot find it for March to October, thus making every "Complete the no hitter" challenge nearly impossible due to muscle memory being wrong and causing Buster Posey to have an infield single
Try doing it from the main menu under mode-specific options. Should say something about player lock and RTTS in there.
Settings > fielding > RTTS fielding interface change to button accuracy. Done in game.