Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever"
-
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
-
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
Trout isn’t a generational talent? I’ll be shocked if ohtani ever has a 10 fWAR season, which trout has two of. I doubt ohtani ever even gets a 9 fWAR season, of which trout has 5.
Sure, ohtani is pitching and hitting. He’s putting up value like every other major leaguer, just in a unique way. At the end of the day though, value is value, and he will never be as statistically valuable as mike trout.
And it’s far from guaranteed that ohtani will be able to do what he’s been doing for years to come anyways. He’s already had some injury history, and it’s not like he’s 21 either. We’ll see how long his body will be able to keep up with both pitching and hitting.
Awards don’t determine whether one season is better than another, statistics do. And statistically, ohtani isn’t even close to trout’s top 7 seasons. Doing something differently doesn’t mean it’s better.
-
@jogger171717_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
Trout isn’t a generational talent? I’ll be shocked if ohtani ever has a 10 fWAR season, which trout has two of. I doubt ohtani ever even gets a 9 fWAR season, of which trout has 5.
Sure, ohtani is pitching and hitting. He’s putting up value like every other major leaguer, just in a unique way. At the end of the day though, value is value, and he will never be as statistically valuable as mike trout.
And it’s far from guaranteed that ohtani will be able to do what he’s been doing for years to come anyways. He’s already had some injury history, and it’s not like he’s 21 either. We’ll see how long his body will be able to keep up with both pitching and hitting.
Awards don’t determine whether one season is better than another, statistics do. And statistically, ohtani isn’t even close to trout’s top 7 seasons. Doing something differently doesn’t mean it’s better.
Not even close? Come on bro, most homers Trout’s had in a season is 45 and Ohtani is about to pass that easily. That same season Trout had 27 doubles, 2 Triples & 104 RBI’s with 11 SB. Ohtani will do better than all of that this season. Not to mention he’s also pitched every 5 days and only lost ONCE this year. Trout has never had one single season with 30+ homers, 100+ RBI & 30 SB, however Ohtani has a chance to have 50+ Homers, 100+RBI’s & 30 SB if he gets enough opportunities. Like I said, I love Trout and he had an amazing first decade, but there’s tons of legends like Lou Gehrig whose careers weren’t completed properly, & I already see that happening to Trout as he becomes older and more injury prone. I’m also not Saying that Ohtani is going to do this every season for the rest of mankind, I said this will go down as the best overall single season by a player in baseball history. There’s no telling what the future holds for him but he has the potential to get even better, let’s give a 5 year wait on Ohtani & Trout then we can come back and compare those seasons to see who is currently playing at a higher level. Watch Ohtani become a 20 game winner with a sub 3 ERA, 40 bombs and 120RBI’s then try to tell me that Trout is more of a generational talent. Acuña’s stats look a whole lot like a young trout, so it didn’t take long to get another Talent like him.
-
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jogger171717_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
Trout isn’t a generational talent? I’ll be shocked if ohtani ever has a 10 fWAR season, which trout has two of. I doubt ohtani ever even gets a 9 fWAR season, of which trout has 5.
Sure, ohtani is pitching and hitting. He’s putting up value like every other major leaguer, just in a unique way. At the end of the day though, value is value, and he will never be as statistically valuable as mike trout.
And it’s far from guaranteed that ohtani will be able to do what he’s been doing for years to come anyways. He’s already had some injury history, and it’s not like he’s 21 either. We’ll see how long his body will be able to keep up with both pitching and hitting.
Awards don’t determine whether one season is better than another, statistics do. And statistically, ohtani isn’t even close to trout’s top 7 seasons. Doing something differently doesn’t mean it’s better.
Not even close? Come on bro, most homers Trout’s had in a season is 45 and Ohtani is about to pass that easily. That same season Trout had 27 doubles, 2 Triples & 104 RBI’s with 11 SB. Ohtani will do better than all of that this season. Not to mention he’s also pitched every 5 days and only lost ONCE this year. Trout has never had one single season with 30+ homers, 100+ RBI & 30 SB, however Ohtani has a chance to have 50+ Homers, 100+RBI’s & 30 SB if he gets enough opportunities. Like I said, I love Trout and he had an amazing first decade, but there’s tons of legends like Lou Gehrig whose careers weren’t completed properly, & I already see that happening to Trout as he becomes older and more injury prone. I’m also not Saying that Ohtani is going to do this every season for the rest of mankind, I said this will go down as the best overall single season by a player in baseball history. There’s no telling what the future holds for him but he has the potential to get even better, let’s give a 5 year wait on Ohtani & Trout then we can come back and compare those seasons to see who is currently playing at a higher level. Watch Ohtani become a 20 game winner with a sub 3 ERA, 40 bombs and 120RBI’s then try to tell me that Trout is more of a generational talent. Acuña’s stats look a whole lot like a young trout, so it didn’t take long to get another Talent like him.
They are putting too much value on WAR like I said earlier in this thread. WAR simply just means wins above replacement. More value is put in WAR at certain positions even if they have the same stats. So the level of a replacement at that position changes yearly and definitely generationally. Also ballparks are factored into war and they were way different a hundred years ago. People that use it as the end all be all are clueless.
https://www.mlb.com/glossary/advanced-stats/wins-above-replacement
-
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jogger171717_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
Trout isn’t a generational talent? I’ll be shocked if ohtani ever has a 10 fWAR season, which trout has two of. I doubt ohtani ever even gets a 9 fWAR season, of which trout has 5.
Sure, ohtani is pitching and hitting. He’s putting up value like every other major leaguer, just in a unique way. At the end of the day though, value is value, and he will never be as statistically valuable as mike trout.
And it’s far from guaranteed that ohtani will be able to do what he’s been doing for years to come anyways. He’s already had some injury history, and it’s not like he’s 21 either. We’ll see how long his body will be able to keep up with both pitching and hitting.
Awards don’t determine whether one season is better than another, statistics do. And statistically, ohtani isn’t even close to trout’s top 7 seasons. Doing something differently doesn’t mean it’s better.
Not even close? Come on bro, most homers Trout’s had in a season is 45 and Ohtani is about to pass that easily. That same season Trout had 27 doubles, 2 Triples & 104 RBI’s with 11 SB. Ohtani will do better than all of that this season. Not to mention he’s also pitched every 5 days and only lost ONCE this year. Trout has never had one single season with 30+ homers, 100+ RBI & 30 SB, however Ohtani has a chance to have 50+ Homers, 100+RBI’s & 30 SB if he gets enough opportunities. Like I said, I love Trout and he had an amazing first decade, but there’s tons of legends like Lou Gehrig whose careers weren’t completed properly, & I already see that happening to Trout as he becomes older and more injury prone. I’m also not Saying that Ohtani is going to do this every season for the rest of mankind, I said this will go down as the best overall single season by a player in baseball history. There’s no telling what the future holds for him but he has the potential to get even better, let’s give a 5 year wait on Ohtani & Trout then we can come back and compare those seasons to see who is currently playing at a higher level. Watch Ohtani become a 20 game winner with a sub 3 ERA, 40 bombs and 120RBI’s then try to tell me that Trout is more of a generational talent. Acuña’s stats look a whole lot like a young trout, so it didn’t take long to get another Talent like him.
Like I said, ohtani will never have a 10 fWAR season, let alone two of them like trout. Ohtani currently has 7.2 fWAR from pitching and hitting combined. Unless he goes on an incredible hot streak for the rest of the month, he won’t get to 8 fWAR. There’s been many, many non-combined seasons that are better than that. This season isn’t even close to the best all time statistically.
As far as hitting goes, ohtani’s 154 wRC+ is extremely good, but trout has never had below 160 wRC+ in a season for his entire career (other than his 40 game 2011 season).
At the end of the day, ohtani is just putting up value in a unique way. However, being unique doesn’t mean it’s better. 10 fWAR will always be better than the 7-7.5 ohtani likely finishes the season with. Just because he got that value in a different way doesn’t mean it’s somehow a better season.
There’s really no simpler way to explain it, so there’s nothing more to be said.
-
@jogger171717_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jogger171717_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
Trout isn’t a generational talent? I’ll be shocked if ohtani ever has a 10 fWAR season, which trout has two of. I doubt ohtani ever even gets a 9 fWAR season, of which trout has 5.
Sure, ohtani is pitching and hitting. He’s putting up value like every other major leaguer, just in a unique way. At the end of the day though, value is value, and he will never be as statistically valuable as mike trout.
And it’s far from guaranteed that ohtani will be able to do what he’s been doing for years to come anyways. He’s already had some injury history, and it’s not like he’s 21 either. We’ll see how long his body will be able to keep up with both pitching and hitting.
Awards don’t determine whether one season is better than another, statistics do. And statistically, ohtani isn’t even close to trout’s top 7 seasons. Doing something differently doesn’t mean it’s better.
Not even close? Come on bro, most homers Trout’s had in a season is 45 and Ohtani is about to pass that easily. That same season Trout had 27 doubles, 2 Triples & 104 RBI’s with 11 SB. Ohtani will do better than all of that this season. Not to mention he’s also pitched every 5 days and only lost ONCE this year. Trout has never had one single season with 30+ homers, 100+ RBI & 30 SB, however Ohtani has a chance to have 50+ Homers, 100+RBI’s & 30 SB if he gets enough opportunities. Like I said, I love Trout and he had an amazing first decade, but there’s tons of legends like Lou Gehrig whose careers weren’t completed properly, & I already see that happening to Trout as he becomes older and more injury prone. I’m also not Saying that Ohtani is going to do this every season for the rest of mankind, I said this will go down as the best overall single season by a player in baseball history. There’s no telling what the future holds for him but he has the potential to get even better, let’s give a 5 year wait on Ohtani & Trout then we can come back and compare those seasons to see who is currently playing at a higher level. Watch Ohtani become a 20 game winner with a sub 3 ERA, 40 bombs and 120RBI’s then try to tell me that Trout is more of a generational talent. Acuña’s stats look a whole lot like a young trout, so it didn’t take long to get another Talent like him.
Like I said, ohtani will never have a 10 fWAR season, let alone two of them like trout. Ohtani currently has 7.2 fWAR from pitching and hitting combined. Unless he goes on an incredible hot streak for the rest of the month, he won’t get to 8 fWAR. There’s been many, many non-combined seasons that are better than that. This season isn’t even close to the best all time statistically.
As far as hitting goes, ohtani’s 154 wRC+ is extremely good, but trout has never had below 160 wRC+ in a season for his entire career (other than his 40 game 2011 season).
At the end of the day, ohtani is just putting up value in a unique way. However, being unique doesn’t mean it’s better. 10 fWAR will always be better than the 7-7.5 ohtani likely finishes the season with. Just because he got that value in a different way doesn’t mean it’s somehow a better season.
There’s really no simpler way to explain it, so there’s nothing more to be said.
Yes there is more to be said sir, you are just out of rebuttals. As Chuck said, WAR shouldn’t be focused on when you’re talking about how good a season was because that only compares you to the average replacement at that specific position. So for one, cool Trout is a lot better than the other CF’s in the 2010’s, not a big surprise it’s been about RF’s this decade other than trout and now acuña. & WAR doesn’t account for Ohtani’s efficiency because he has to cover the comparison of 2 positions. For example, since he’s a starter his “replacement,” would be considered a healthy guy that gets his 30 starts in + his replacement would also be your average DH, so it’s just statistically unlikely to out perform 2 replacements at the same time compared to Trout only having to outperform his CF replacement. Because of this WAR is quickly becoming an obsolete stat in baseball and we are soon going to have a better way to grade a players efficiency and success, starting with finding the proper way to adjust a two way player like Ohtani to a Star like Trout. I’m my opinion, Ohtani gets injured and you need 2 maybe 3 people to fill his spot. However without Trout, they’re actually doing pretty similar to what they do with him and all’s they did was call up some minor leaguers. (Adell & Marsh) I’m not trying to downplay Trout’s seasons, I have repeatedly said that he’s amazing. I just think what Ohtani can do is more impressive, athletic, skillful, talented, and it’s just downright ridiculous. It’s a blessing and a pleasure every time he pitches, I’ve tuned in to every start this year and I’m super excited about tonight against the Astros! Stros are my favorite team so this one looks like it could be a game of the year. & honestly I think Trout is gonna play too!!!
-
@chuckclc_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jogger171717_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
Trout isn’t a generational talent? I’ll be shocked if ohtani ever has a 10 fWAR season, which trout has two of. I doubt ohtani ever even gets a 9 fWAR season, of which trout has 5.
Sure, ohtani is pitching and hitting. He’s putting up value like every other major leaguer, just in a unique way. At the end of the day though, value is value, and he will never be as statistically valuable as mike trout.
And it’s far from guaranteed that ohtani will be able to do what he’s been doing for years to come anyways. He’s already had some injury history, and it’s not like he’s 21 either. We’ll see how long his body will be able to keep up with both pitching and hitting.
Awards don’t determine whether one season is better than another, statistics do. And statistically, ohtani isn’t even close to trout’s top 7 seasons. Doing something differently doesn’t mean it’s better.
Not even close? Come on bro, most homers Trout’s had in a season is 45 and Ohtani is about to pass that easily. That same season Trout had 27 doubles, 2 Triples & 104 RBI’s with 11 SB. Ohtani will do better than all of that this season. Not to mention he’s also pitched every 5 days and only lost ONCE this year. Trout has never had one single season with 30+ homers, 100+ RBI & 30 SB, however Ohtani has a chance to have 50+ Homers, 100+RBI’s & 30 SB if he gets enough opportunities. Like I said, I love Trout and he had an amazing first decade, but there’s tons of legends like Lou Gehrig whose careers weren’t completed properly, & I already see that happening to Trout as he becomes older and more injury prone. I’m also not Saying that Ohtani is going to do this every season for the rest of mankind, I said this will go down as the best overall single season by a player in baseball history. There’s no telling what the future holds for him but he has the potential to get even better, let’s give a 5 year wait on Ohtani & Trout then we can come back and compare those seasons to see who is currently playing at a higher level. Watch Ohtani become a 20 game winner with a sub 3 ERA, 40 bombs and 120RBI’s then try to tell me that Trout is more of a generational talent. Acuña’s stats look a whole lot like a young trout, so it didn’t take long to get another Talent like him.
They are putting too much value on WAR like I said earlier in this thread. WAR simply just means wins above replacement. More value is put in WAR at certain positions even if they have the same stats. So the level of a replacement at that position changes yearly and definitely generationally. Also ballparks are factored into war and they were way different a hundred years ago. People that use it as the end all be all are clueless.
https://www.mlb.com/glossary/advanced-stats/wins-above-replacement
There’s different types of WAR, all of them say Ohtani isn’t having a top 100 season. Even other stats, traditional numbers like batting average show Ohtani hitting .100 points lower than Ruth and also pitching .8 ERA higher. It’s not close
-
@chandaman625_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
He’s possibly going to be the only player ever to win the Mvp, Cy young award, Silver slugger, and depending on how Vladdy & Salvy’s seasons end, even possibly the Hank Aaron award. You say a triple crown is impressive, then how about a full award sweep? That’s not the most impressive single season ever to you? & not the best player on his team? Sure, let me see Trout try to hit 50 homers, with 25 swiped bags, and an 11-2 record with a sub 3 ERA against today’s American League. Ohtani would crush trout if he pitched to him, & I bet Trout prays that he never has to hit against Ohtani. Besides Ohtani is younger than trout so he even has more potential to achieve a better season compared to Trout. I love Mike Trout but he’s not the same as Ohtani, Trout is a talent of the decade and will forever be remembered for his quick ascension to greatness. As for Shohei, he’s a generational talent, like a Babe Ruth or Willie Mays. There’s only one that can do what he does, to the full extent of what he does, as great as he does it. & there won’t be another man to recreate his season until your great grandkids have grandkids.
Ohtani will not win Cy Young and I also won’t be telling my grandkids about Ohtani either
-
I have been a big proponent of WAR as a measurement, but cant figure out the discrepancy in a comparison I saw the other day. Maybe someone who is more knowledgeable can explain it to me. Looking back at the 1993 Cy Young leaders, Greg Maddux won the award but Jose Rijo is listed as having a WAR of 9.2 compared to 5.8 for Maddux. That is a very large difference that should illustrate that Rijo was monumentally better that season than Maddux.
Comparing the numbers though, I just dont get it.
Maddux threw more innings, with less walks, WHIP, HR allowed, and is better in ERA+, with 4x the number of CG as Rijo. The only things I see that Rijo takes, are Ks and HBP. Even looking at the advanced metrics, Maddux was better in OBP, SLG, OPS, BAbip, and WPA. The only thing Rijo takes there was BA by .230 to .232.
Can anyone helpfully explain why Rijo has a WAR that blows Maddux away that season when all the numbers I see dont appear to back that up?
-
@KDClemson_PSN
Ohtani definitely won't win Cy Young this year but he definitely has the potential to win one in the next few years. If he won a Cy Young and MVP in the same year that would be pretty impressive. I'm not comparing the guy to Babe but he is a very impressive player. To deny that would just be ignorant. -
@kovz88_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@KDClemson_PSN
Ohtani definitely won't win Cy Young this year but he definitely has the potential to win one in the next few years. If he won a Cy Young and MVP in the same year that would be pretty impressive. I'm not comparing the guy to Babe but he is a very impressive player. To deny that would just be ignorant.Cy Young and MVP (as a hitter/position player) is what I'm assuming you meant. There have been plenty of players that have won both awards in the same season.
-
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chuckclc_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
Lets not pretend WAR is the end all be all of evaluating a player. How well did Babe pitch in those seasons? Babe definitely has the most impressive hitting numbers of all time, but when you add in Pitching and Speed it does become a legit argument between the 2.
Plus of course the obvious 100 hundred year difference in athletic era. Apples and Oranges.
Between hitting, pitching and speed.
Babe was miles better hitting, miles better pitching, and slightly worse if that in speed.“Slightly worse in speed” Ohtani is literally as fast as Olympic sprinters of babe Ruth’s era, ya know, the fastest people in the world
-
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chuckclc_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
Lets not pretend WAR is the end all be all of evaluating a player. How well did Babe pitch in those seasons? Babe definitely has the most impressive hitting numbers of all time, but when you add in Pitching and Speed it does become a legit argument between the 2.
Plus of course the obvious 100 hundred year difference in athletic era. Apples and Oranges.
Between hitting, pitching and speed.
Babe was miles better hitting, miles better pitching, and slightly worse if that in speed.“Slightly worse in speed” Ohtani is literally as fast as Olympic sprinters of babe Ruth’s era, ya know, the fastest people in the world
Ok each generation gets more physically dominant than the previous. Have Ohtani born in 1900 and he’s barely faster than Ruth if at all
-
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chuckclc_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
Lets not pretend WAR is the end all be all of evaluating a player. How well did Babe pitch in those seasons? Babe definitely has the most impressive hitting numbers of all time, but when you add in Pitching and Speed it does become a legit argument between the 2.
Plus of course the obvious 100 hundred year difference in athletic era. Apples and Oranges.
Between hitting, pitching and speed.
Babe was miles better hitting, miles better pitching, and slightly worse if that in speed.“Slightly worse in speed” Ohtani is literally as fast as Olympic sprinters of babe Ruth’s era, ya know, the fastest people in the world
Ok each generation gets more physically dominant than the previous. Have Ohtani born in 1900 and he’s barely faster than Ruth if at all
So you’ll concede that ohtani is stronger, faster, and more athletic than Ruth? And that the era each player plays in carries significant weight in evaluating their performance?
-
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chuckclc_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
Lets not pretend WAR is the end all be all of evaluating a player. How well did Babe pitch in those seasons? Babe definitely has the most impressive hitting numbers of all time, but when you add in Pitching and Speed it does become a legit argument between the 2.
Plus of course the obvious 100 hundred year difference in athletic era. Apples and Oranges.
Between hitting, pitching and speed.
Babe was miles better hitting, miles better pitching, and slightly worse if that in speed.“Slightly worse in speed” Ohtani is literally as fast as Olympic sprinters of babe Ruth’s era, ya know, the fastest people in the world
Ok each generation gets more physically dominant than the previous. Have Ohtani born in 1900 and he’s barely faster than Ruth if at all
So you’ll concede that ohtani is stronger, faster, and more athletic than Ruth? And that the era each player plays in carries significant weight in evaluating their performance?
Yes and that Ruth was more exponentially more dominant among his peers than Ohtani was
-
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chuckclc_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
Lets not pretend WAR is the end all be all of evaluating a player. How well did Babe pitch in those seasons? Babe definitely has the most impressive hitting numbers of all time, but when you add in Pitching and Speed it does become a legit argument between the 2.
Plus of course the obvious 100 hundred year difference in athletic era. Apples and Oranges.
Between hitting, pitching and speed.
Babe was miles better hitting, miles better pitching, and slightly worse if that in speed.“Slightly worse in speed” Ohtani is literally as fast as Olympic sprinters of babe Ruth’s era, ya know, the fastest people in the world
Ok each generation gets more physically dominant than the previous. Have Ohtani born in 1900 and he’s barely faster than Ruth if at all
So you’ll concede that ohtani is stronger, faster, and more athletic than Ruth? And that the era each player plays in carries significant weight in evaluating their performance?
Yes and that Ruth was more exponentially more dominant among his peers than Ohtani was
So it’s fair to say a player that dominated an inferior league is not as talented as one that is dominating the big leagues today? The worst hitter in today’s game would hit 45 homers a hundred years ago
-
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@jacksonvance35 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@kdclemson_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@chuckclc_psn said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
Lets not pretend WAR is the end all be all of evaluating a player. How well did Babe pitch in those seasons? Babe definitely has the most impressive hitting numbers of all time, but when you add in Pitching and Speed it does become a legit argument between the 2.
Plus of course the obvious 100 hundred year difference in athletic era. Apples and Oranges.
Between hitting, pitching and speed.
Babe was miles better hitting, miles better pitching, and slightly worse if that in speed.“Slightly worse in speed” Ohtani is literally as fast as Olympic sprinters of babe Ruth’s era, ya know, the fastest people in the world
Ok each generation gets more physically dominant than the previous. Have Ohtani born in 1900 and he’s barely faster than Ruth if at all
So you’ll concede that ohtani is stronger, faster, and more athletic than Ruth? And that the era each player plays in carries significant weight in evaluating their performance?
Yes and that Ruth was more exponentially more dominant among his peers than Ohtani was
So it’s fair to say a player that dominated an inferior league is not as talented as one that is dominating the big leagues today? The worst hitter in today’s game would hit 45 homers a hundred years ago
Not if they grew up in the 1900s, no they wouldn't have.
-
@poksey_mlbts said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
I have been a big proponent of WAR as a measurement, but cant figure out the discrepancy in a comparison I saw the other day. Maybe someone who is more knowledgeable can explain it to me. Looking back at the 1993 Cy Young leaders, Greg Maddux won the award but Jose Rijo is listed as having a WAR of 9.2 compared to 5.8 for Maddux. That is a very large difference that should illustrate that Rijo was monumentally better that season than Maddux.
Comparing the numbers though, I just dont get it.
Maddux threw more innings, with less walks, WHIP, HR allowed, and is better in ERA+, with 4x the number of CG as Rijo. The only things I see that Rijo takes, are Ks and HBP. Even looking at the advanced metrics, Maddux was better in OBP, SLG, OPS, BAbip, and WPA. The only thing Rijo takes there was BA by .230 to .232.
Can anyone helpfully explain why Rijo has a WAR that blows Maddux away that season when all the numbers I see dont appear to back that up?
Anybody help me out on this?
-
@poksey_mlbts said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@poksey_mlbts said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
I have been a big proponent of WAR as a measurement, but cant figure out the discrepancy in a comparison I saw the other day. Maybe someone who is more knowledgeable can explain it to me. Looking back at the 1993 Cy Young leaders, Greg Maddux won the award but Jose Rijo is listed as having a WAR of 9.2 compared to 5.8 for Maddux. That is a very large difference that should illustrate that Rijo was monumentally better that season than Maddux.
Comparing the numbers though, I just dont get it.
Maddux threw more innings, with less walks, WHIP, HR allowed, and is better in ERA+, with 4x the number of CG as Rijo. The only things I see that Rijo takes, are Ks and HBP. Even looking at the advanced metrics, Maddux was better in OBP, SLG, OPS, BAbip, and WPA. The only thing Rijo takes there was BA by .230 to .232.
Can anyone helpfully explain why Rijo has a WAR that blows Maddux away that season when all the numbers I see dont appear to back that up?
Anybody help me out on this?
Pitching WAR weighs strikeouts far more heavily than any other attribute. Pitchers who pitch to contact will always have lower WAR than strikeout pitchers because of the ball being put into play far more often. A strikeout pitcher will have less balls in play usually resulting in lower averages against him. The batters will not reach base unless the catcher fails to catch the pitch. We all know that Maddux didn’t rely on strikeouts to get by instead he relied on the batters to get themselves out by chasing pitches that he wanted them to chase resulting in a lot of weak contact. This is also why WAR is really not a good measuring stick for pitchers. It doesn’t weigh the peripheral attributes high enough for it to be a reasonable statistic. For example: Max Fried has one of the highest pitching WAR’s in the NL. I think he only trails 2 pitchers in this category however, there is not a sane person out there that would say he is a Cy young candidate. Heck he isn’t even the best pitcher on his own team. Not saying he isn’t good, he is definitely a top 10 pitcher in the NL just not this year.
-
@killerpresence4 said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@poksey_mlbts said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
@poksey_mlbts said in Ohtani's "Greatest Season Ever":
I have been a big proponent of WAR as a measurement, but cant figure out the discrepancy in a comparison I saw the other day. Maybe someone who is more knowledgeable can explain it to me. Looking back at the 1993 Cy Young leaders, Greg Maddux won the award but Jose Rijo is listed as having a WAR of 9.2 compared to 5.8 for Maddux. That is a very large difference that should illustrate that Rijo was monumentally better that season than Maddux.
Comparing the numbers though, I just dont get it.
Maddux threw more innings, with less walks, WHIP, HR allowed, and is better in ERA+, with 4x the number of CG as Rijo. The only things I see that Rijo takes, are Ks and HBP. Even looking at the advanced metrics, Maddux was better in OBP, SLG, OPS, BAbip, and WPA. The only thing Rijo takes there was BA by .230 to .232.
Can anyone helpfully explain why Rijo has a WAR that blows Maddux away that season when all the numbers I see dont appear to back that up?
Anybody help me out on this?
Pitching WAR weighs strikeouts far more heavily than any other attribute. Pitchers who pitch to contact will always have lower WAR than strikeout pitchers because of the ball being put into play far more often. A strikeout pitcher will have less balls in play usually resulting in lower averages against him. The batters will not reach base unless the catcher fails to catch the pitch. We all know that Maddux didn’t rely on strikeouts to get by instead he relied on the batters to get themselves out by chasing pitches that he wanted them to chase resulting in a lot of weak contact. This is also why WAR is really not a good measuring stick for pitchers. It doesn’t weigh the peripheral attributes high enough for it to be a reasonable statistic. For example: Max Fried has one of the highest pitching WAR’s in the NL. I think he only trails 2 pitchers in this category however, there is not a sane person out there that would say he is a Cy young candidate. Heck he isn’t even the best pitcher on his own team. Not saying he isn’t good, he is definitely a top 10 pitcher in the NL just not this year.
There is no way that is the answer to why Rijo 9.2 WAR, and Maddux 5.8 WAR in 1993. I appreciate the response, but there is just no way.
Rijo had 227 Ks in 257 IP
Maddux 197 Ks in 267 IPIt's not that big of a difference to cause a 3.4 higher rated WAR. Adding onto that, Kevin Appier had a 9.3 WAR that season and had 186 Ks.
I also had to look up this season pitchers, and Fried is 13th in WAR in the NL.
