Pitcher batting instead of DH

[WinnieThaPuHole_PSN]

Hey there. Is anyone else having an issue with their pitchers being locked into bat where the DH should be? I can move their batting order around but I can’t sub out the pitcher for an actual DH. However whichever team I play against, they have a DH batting instead of their pitcher. Any help is appreciated. Thank you!

[RikStarr1970_XBL]

If you’re an American League team visiting a national league team then your dh spot gets replaced by pitcher. If American League vs another American League team then you hit as dh. National league teams have pitcher[censored]ting instead of Dh.

[WinnieThaPuHole_PSN]

Yes, I know that. But in my settings I have DH always on. I’m playing as the blue jays against other AL teams and they have a DH and I have my pitcher batting instead of my DH