Pitching accuracy suddenly gone

[DashingCN_XBL]

I went to practice hitting on legend and as soon as I revert back my hitting settings, the aim online is gone. Suddenly the same motions on the right stick (I pitch with that option) I did before this practice are late and cause the balls to drop or move away from the spot more than before. Same if its good or early, its just not going to the general spot

Any idea if they changed something, I messed something up, or I'm just being paranoid since I can't get good at the game with my hitting while pitching I'm fine with except that one pitch to let them score and I can't come back.