What to do with Trevor Story???
-
I would sell. Honestly I feel like SDS is going to keep buffing LS Tatis w/ Trout out. Card is already up 40k from when I bought him. Dude is on pace for 50/40 and SDS refuses to acknowledge he can’t play defense
-
@pats1124_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
I would sell. Honestly I feel like SDS is going to keep buffing LS Tatis w/ Trout out. Card is already up 40k from when I bought him. Dude is on pace for 50/40 and SDS refuses to acknowledge he can’t play defense
But he's getting super expensive as well. A POTM Semien that should be eligible at ss would settle it but that's only in a week
-
@mlbts_mlbts said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
Sell. Gonna be better guys at SS pretty soon.
Press x to doubt, no arod rights, no better all around shortstops unless we get a lindor flashback that has more than 60 power (sds hates his power so good luck lol)
-
No better SS than a Story released in May? Funny as we had tons of better SSs last year not to mention The Hawk CAP. No doubt we will see a 99 Tatis at some point not to mention Honus and likely many others. Not a knock on Story but there isn’t a single “endgame” card right now besides maybe Chipper.
-
I didn't know Trevor Story's mother posted on these forums.
-
Who was better? Honus is comparable, more versatile. He would be equal to Story probably. Not better necessarily better. If Story isn’t endgame then what’s his weakness? Low vision? Vision only matters for fouling balls off.
-
His attributes aren’t over 99. You will see “endgame” players with more speed and power/contact. Seager didn’t have speed LY but his 99 to me was better as he’s a lefty but again not a knock. There isn’t a better SS available “right now” and that’s a fair statement but could still be debated as some people prefer switch hitters if not lefties.
-
@rosborn27_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
No better SS than a Story released in May? Funny as we had tons of better SSs last year not to mention The Hawk CAP. No doubt we will see a 99 Tatis at some point not to mention Honus and likely many others. Not a knock on Story but there isn’t a single “endgame” card right now besides maybe Chipper.
Ok cap doesn't count for a "content release" debate, honus power and swing worse, tatis swing and vision will be worse so I guess you could say comparable
But no arod..no better SS period
-
@rosborn27_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
His attributes aren’t over 99. You will see “endgame” players with more speed and power/contact. Seager didn’t have speed LY but his 99 to me was better as he’s a lefty but again not a knock. There isn’t a better SS available “right now” and that’s a fair statement but could still be debated as some people prefer switch hitters if not lefties.
More speed with 95+ power/contact and 99 fielding/reaction? Just give me one example lol
-
@rosborn27_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
His attributes aren’t over 99. You will see “endgame” players with more speed and power/contact. Seager didn’t have speed LY but his 99 to me was better as he’s a lefty but again not a knock. There isn’t a better SS available “right now” and that’s a fair statement but could still be debated as some people prefer switch hitters if not lefties.
Seager has a noodle arm and iffy glove and no speed, better 2b/3b
And what switch hitting ss would their be aside from lindor flashback with ACTUAL pop which sds never gives him
-
You made me load The Show 20 but ok. Had every card so:
Prestige Honus: 119/125 Contact, 92/93 Power, Diamond defense and 98 Speed/99 Steal
Postseason Seager: 118/120 Contact, 113/122 Power, Gold Defense, 47 Speed. But Lefty and glitchy.
99 Prestige Tatis: 122/93 Contact, 125/114 Power, Diamond Defense, 87 Speed
98 Mondesi: Glitchy as F
99 Prestige Ramirez (secondary): 98/125 Contact, 106/125 Power, Gold Defense, 64 Speed
[censored] I’ll throw in 99 Gavin Lux: 114/91 Contact, 108/98 Power, Gold Defense, 80 Speed
99 Prestige Machado (secondary): 112/119 Contact, 114/123 Power, Diamond defense, 49 Speed
Point is, a lot of cards are yet to come.
-
@rosborn27_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
You made me load The Show 20 but ok. Had every card so:
Prestige Honus: 119/125 Contact, 92/93 Power, Diamond defense and 98 Speed/99 Steal
Postseason Seager: 118/120 Contact, 113/122 Power, Gold Defense, 47 Speed. But Lefty and glitchy.
99 Prestige Tatis: 122/93 Contact, 125/114 Power, Diamond Defense, 87 Speed
98 Mondesi: Glitchy as F
99 Prestige Ramirez (secondary): 98/125 Contact, 106/125 Power, Gold Defense, 64 Speed
[censored] I’ll throw in 99 Gavin Lux: 114/91 Contact, 108/98 Power, Gold Defense, 80 Speed
99 Prestige Machado (secondary): 112/119 Contact, 114/123 Power, Diamond defense, 49 Speed
Point is, a lot of cards are yet to come.
Honus is the only one comparable if we’re splitting hairs. Tatis finest would be right there with Story like I mentioned earlier. Looking for a 5 tool player. Below 80 speed and you’re going to see a big dip in range. Just the way this game plays.
-
@rosborn27_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
No better SS than a Story released in May? Funny as we had tons of better SSs last year not to mention The Hawk CAP. No doubt we will see a 99 Tatis at some point not to mention Honus and likely many others. Not a knock on Story but there isn’t a single “endgame” card right now besides maybe Chipper.
If Fernando Tatis has anything higher than Silver fielding ill be upset.
-
@ncstatehokie_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@thehungryhole said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
KEEP HOMIE
END GAME SS FOR MOI
I'm assuming you are a Rockies fan?
not even buddy i just rake with his LS and love the card
-
Sell him and work on finishing your collections
-
@genopolanco_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@mlbts_mlbts said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@umpshow666_xbl said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@mlbts_mlbts said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
Sell. Gonna be better guys at SS pretty soon.
That Groshans kid from TA2 is not Story but pretty close (and free)
What would you rather take? Groshans that is pretty close to Story and free and get 200k stubs or Trevor Story even though there will be better shortstops released?
Who exactly is going to better?
Larkin? No.
Maybe a better Banks in September?A parallel 5 Story is endgame without a doubt. 92 speed, 99 fielding, 99 reaction, 97 arm, 95+ in every important hitting category.
I don’t know any other 5 tool SSs that can drop until a Finest Tatis or maybe a juiced Lindor. And even then it will be preference.
You obviously don't know anything about the cap. Makes Trevor story look like a child.
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@genopolanco_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@mlbts_mlbts said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@umpshow666_xbl said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@mlbts_mlbts said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
Sell. Gonna be better guys at SS pretty soon.
That Groshans kid from TA2 is not Story but pretty close (and free)
What would you rather take? Groshans that is pretty close to Story and free and get 200k stubs or Trevor Story even though there will be better shortstops released?
Who exactly is going to better?
Larkin? No.
Maybe a better Banks in September?A parallel 5 Story is endgame without a doubt. 92 speed, 99 fielding, 99 reaction, 97 arm, 95+ in every important hitting category.
I don’t know any other 5 tool SSs that can drop until a Finest Tatis or maybe a juiced Lindor. And even then it will be preference.
You obviously don't know anything about the cap. Makes Trevor story look like a child.
I don’t include CAPs in how I evaluate players because I don’t use them.
-
Another Story is about to be released into the wild thanks to a Steve Finely walk off to go 9-1 and put me at 100. Eases the sting of losing my 8-0 game despite being up 6-0 — ouch....
-
@ncstatehokie_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@thehungryhole said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
KEEP HOMIE
END GAME SS FOR MOI
I'm assuming you are a Rockies fan?
My thoughts exactly because trevor is not all that in this game
-
@bossplaya1_xbl said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@ncstatehokie_psn said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
@thehungryhole said in What to do with Trevor Story???:
KEEP HOMIE
END GAME SS FOR MOI
I'm assuming you are a Rockies fan?
My thoughts exactly because trevor is not all that in this game
Hes all that and a bag of chips.
-
A admin locked this topic on
