POTM?
-
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
Semien has been nuts. And played all month unlike Tatis
I’m not sure pointing out the dude that had 1 more hr, less rbis and 6 less SB played all month over the other dude really makes the point you think it does.
I think it does. He helped his team all month and put up a 1.132 OPS.
Tatis has played in half the games for his team and put up even better numbers for HR and SB, sure . But how does playing in half your team's games help your case?
Nobody else is close to Semien who played all month... So you'd give POTM to a guy who didn't help his team at all half the time?
Yea I would. Most players would want Tatis too I would think. He would be buxton with a better swing.
Tatis' live series is in the range where he wouldn't get a POTM card unless it is a 99, which this won't be.
-
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
Semien has been nuts. And played all month unlike Tatis
I’m not sure pointing out the dude that had 1 more hr, less rbis and 6 less SB played all month over the other dude really makes the point you think it does.
I think it does. He helped his team all month and put up a 1.132 OPS.
Tatis has played in half the games for his team and put up even better numbers for HR and SB, sure . But how does playing in half your team's games help your case?
Nobody else is close to Semien who played all month... So you'd give POTM to a guy who didn't help his team at all half the time?
Yea I would. Most players would want Tatis too I would think. He would be buxton with a better swing.
You missed the point. Ya sure people want tatis..
But potm would go to a player who played every game at 1.132 OPS over a player who played half the games at 1.312 OPS. End of story. -
I feel like at this stage of PotM and Topps Now, the guys who are get cards are the ones who’s LS are in Gold/ Silver/ Bronze. A guy like Tatis or deGrom or Acuna would have to get a 98 or 99 to be worth it at this point, and there are still 4 months of the season plus postseason and finest cards they are going to have to wait for
-
Rich Hill
Max Muncy
Trevor Rogers -
Tatis will get one later im sure, you want him to get a 99 like his card last year. I would throw Adolis Garcias name in the hat for this release, he has been playing out of his mind all season but he did get a Topps now card already.
-
Brandon Woodruff - 42.0 IP, 1.07 ERA, 0.667 WHIP, 49/8 K/BB
-
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
Semien has been nuts. And played all month unlike Tatis
I’m not sure pointing out the dude that had 1 more hr, less rbis and 6 less SB played all month over the other dude really makes the point you think it does.
I think it does. He helped his team all month and put up a 1.132 OPS.
Tatis has played in half the games for his team and put up even better numbers for HR and SB, sure . But how does playing in half your team's games help your case?
Nobody else is close to Semien who played all month... So you'd give POTM to a guy who didn't help his team at all half the time?
Yea I would. Most players would want Tatis too I would think. He would be buxton with a better swing.
I get you’re a blue jays fan but he could still get a card. Like a 93 or whatever. But I’m just guessing so maybe it’s Semien.
I think Semien should definitely get a card on the way to POTM
-
Rich Hill was lights out. Gotta have a card
-
@thelowrie5_psn said in POTM?:
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
Semien has been nuts. And played all month unlike Tatis
I’m not sure pointing out the dude that had 1 more hr, less rbis and 6 less SB played all month over the other dude really makes the point you think it does.
I think it does. He helped his team all month and put up a 1.132 OPS.
Tatis has played in half the games for his team and put up even better numbers for HR and SB, sure . But how does playing in half your team's games help your case?
Nobody else is close to Semien who played all month... So you'd give POTM to a guy who didn't help his team at all half the time?
Yea I would. Most players would want Tatis too I would think. He would be buxton with a better swing.
I get you’re a blue jays fan but he could still get a card. Like a 93 or whatever. But I’m just guessing so maybe it’s Semien.
I think Semien should definitely get a card on the way to POTM
On the way? There's more than a 90% chance he is the POTM IRL for the AL, and was #1 in WAR for the month in MLB
-
I think they go pitcher for POTM
-
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
@thelowrie5_psn said in POTM?:
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
@untchable704_psn said in POTM?:
@nanthrax_1_psn said in POTM?:
Semien has been nuts. And played all month unlike Tatis
I’m not sure pointing out the dude that had 1 more hr, less rbis and 6 less SB played all month over the other dude really makes the point you think it does.
I think it does. He helped his team all month and put up a 1.132 OPS.
Tatis has played in half the games for his team and put up even better numbers for HR and SB, sure . But how does playing in half your team's games help your case?
Nobody else is close to Semien who played all month... So you'd give POTM to a guy who didn't help his team at all half the time?
Yea I would. Most players would want Tatis too I would think. He would be buxton with a better swing.
I get you’re a blue jays fan but he could still get a card. Like a 93 or whatever. But I’m just guessing so maybe it’s Semien.
I think Semien should definitely get a card on the way to POTM
On the way? There's more than a 90% chance he is the POTM IRL for the AL, and was #1 in WAR for the month in MLB
I’m okay if he gets it! If he doesnt then second last....but he’s been a beast
-
A admin locked this topic on
