Road to the Show not letting me play my position after rookie season

[Mr Wiggles II_XBL]

This has happened twice now where I get up to a starting spot on a team and the first year finishes. I’m showing as a starter, but I am only ever a DH or or PH my overall is higher than the chump at my back up and I still never get to see the field. This is irritating because I can’t complete my archetype goals because I never see the field for putt outs. Anyone know a fix?