Pudge or Piazza

Finally got my first inning boss and I took Piazza because I wanted an upgrade at catcher. Literally got a bonus pack minutes later and pulled a diamond Pudge. I know there’s only 5000 difference in selling but who would you keep as your catcher? Just curious.

Thanks.

Piazza hitting, Pudge defensive

Thank you. I realize that. What I was asking was if you had to keep one and had to sell one who would you choose? I’m just curious of peoples opinions.

If it is me, I keep Rodriguez. I can't hit anything with piazza at all and I do well with pudge.

What do you play mainly? If it's single player conquest and vs. CPU the defensive makes no difference on any difficulty up through all-star which I always play and even on legendary which I sometimes play.

Piazza has been my best hitter, usually I don't do so well with slower swings but he's been mashing for me and D has been fine.