One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game
-
@bostondirtdog21 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Pedro over Clemens for the Sox. And I love Roger.
If I’m allowed to make one change on this list, it would be to replace Clemens with Pedro. Still can’t believe I left him off
-
Great list and idea for a topic.
Here's my own personal list:
Baltimore Orioles - Mike Mussina, SP
Boston Red Sox - Nomar Garciaparra, SS
New York Yankees - Roger Maris, RF
Tampa Bay Rays - James Shields, SP
Toronto Blue Jays - Roy Halladay, SPChicago White Sox - A.J. Pierzynski, C (or Magglio Ordonez, RF)
Cleveland Indians - Albert Belle, LF
Detroit Tigers - Prince Fielder, 1B
Kansas City Royals - Jermaine Dye, RF
Minnesota Twins - Joe Mauer, CLos Angeles Angels - Francisco "K-Rod" Rodriguez, CP
Oakland Athletics - Barry Zito, SP
Seattle Mariners - Randy Johnson, SP
Texas Rangers - Adrian Beltre, 3B
Houston Astros - Ken Caminiti, 3BAtlanta Braves - Hank Aaron, RF
Miami Marlins - Jose Fernandez, SP (or Dontrelle Willis, SP)
New York Mets - Dwight "Doc" Gooden, SP
Washington Nationals - Andres Galarraga, 1B
Philadelphia Phillies - Chase Utley, 2BChicago Cubs - Carlos Zambrano, SP
Cincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson, OF
Milwaukee Brewers - Ben Sheets, SP
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente, OF
St. Louis Cardinals - Carlos Beltran, OFArizona Diamondbacks - J.J. Putz, CP
Colorado Rockies - Troy Tulowitzki, SS
Los Angeles Dodgers - Hideo Nomo, SP
San Diego Padres - Jake Peavy, SP
San Francisco Giants - Tim Lincecum, SP -
Troy Glaus.
-
@BodamEscapePlan said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Great list and idea for a topic.
Here's my own personal list:
Baltimore Orioles - Mike Mussina, SP
Boston Red Sox - Nomar Garciaparra, SS
New York Yankees - Roger Maris, RF
Tampa Bay Rays - James Shields, SP
Toronto Blue Jays - Roy Halladay, SPChicago White Sox - A.J. Pierzynski, C
Cleveland Indians - Albert Belle, LF
Detroit Tigers - Prince Fielder, 1B
Kansas City Royals - Jermaine Dye, RF
Minnesota Twins - Joe Mauer, CLos Angeles Angels - Francisco "K-Rod" Rodriguez, CP
Oakland Athletics - Barry Zito, SP
Seattle Mariners - Randy Johnson, SP
Texas Rangers - Adrian Beltre, 3B
Houston Astros - Ken Caminiti, 3BAtlanta Braves - Hank Aaron, RF
Miami Marlins - Jose Fernandez, SP
New York Mets - Dwight "Doc" Gooden, SP
Washington Nationals - Andres Galarraga, 1B
Philadelphia Phillies - Chase Utley, 2BChicago Cubs - Carlos Zambrano, SP
Cincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson, OF
Milwaukee Brewers - Ben Sheets, SP
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente, OF
St. Louis Cardinals - Carlos Beltran, OFArizona Diamondbacks - J.J. Putz, CP
Colorado Rockies - Troy Tulowitzki, SS
Los Angeles Dodgers - Hideo Nomo, SP
San Diego Padres - Jake Peavy, SP
San Francisco Giants - Tim Lincecum, SPGreat list. Nomo would be very fun to use. Funny how you have Randy Johnson as a Mariner and JJ Putz as a D back. You could argue keeping both on the list but then just switching teams lol. Jose Fernandez should’ve been on my list. RIP.
-
Give me Al Simmons from the Philadelphia A’s, even over Waddell.
-
@Quint75 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Give me Al Simmons from the Philadelphia A’s, even over Waddell.
I’m actually surprised Al Simmons isn’t in the game already. He’d make my list, but Waddell would just be too much fun. If a player equipped a siren, he would run off the mound looking for the fire truck.
-
I’d love to have Pedro Martinez or Manny Ramirez
-
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Some of these players have been in previous versions of the game, some are virtually impossible due to rights issues, but here is a personal wish list of one player from each team I wish was in The Show.
Atlanta Braves - Hank Aaron
Washington Nationals - Tim Raines
Miami Marlins - Dontrelle Willis
Philadelphia Phillies - Steve Carlton
New York Mets - Dwight GoodenCincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson
Milwaukee Brewers - Cecil Cooper
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente
Chicago Cubs - Ron Santo
St Louis Cardinals - Willie McGeeSan Francisco Giants - Barry Bonds
Los Angeles Dodgers - Fernando Valenzuela
San Diego Padres - Dave Winfield
Arizona Diamondbacks - Randy Johnson
Colorado Rockies - Vinny CastillaNew York Yankees - Derek Jeter
Boston Red Sox - Roger Clemens
Toronto Blue Jays - Dave Stieb
Baltimore Orioles - George Sisler
Tampa Bay Rays - Carl CrawfordCleveland - Albert Belle
Chicago White Sox - Wilbur Wood
Minnesota Twins - Kirby Puckett
Detroit Tigers - Lou Whitaker
Kansas City Royals - Willie WilsonSeattle Mariners - Ichiro Suzuki
Los Angeles Angels - Jim Fregosi
Texas Rangers - Rafael Palmeiro
Houston Astros - J.R. Richard
Oakland Athletics - Rube WaddellDefunct Organizations - Satchel Paige, Josh Gibson, Cool Papa Bell, Jack Glasscock, Old Hoss Radbourn
Did I forget your favorite player? Did I list someone already in the game? Am I a l[censored] moron? Leave your input below. Looking forward to your suggestions and comments.
J.R. Richard, one of the bigger what if's and it would be really cool to see SDS maybe do a couple guys a year to highlight some of them who would have been household names had there careers not been cut tragically short. I think baseball and its fans embrace the games history and former players in a way no oter sport does. I love talking to my son about many of the Legends and passing on the stories my father told me as a kid about guys like Gibson, Koufax, Mantle, Clemente etc.
Clemente and Richard would actually be a pretty good couple guys to start with. Nice list and Stieb was fealty he reallly had some crazy movement
-
@wolfTex77 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Some of these players have been in previous versions of the game, some are virtually impossible due to rights issues, but here is a personal wish list of one player from each team I wish was in The Show.
Atlanta Braves - Hank Aaron
Washington Nationals - Tim Raines
Miami Marlins - Dontrelle Willis
Philadelphia Phillies - Steve Carlton
New York Mets - Dwight GoodenCincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson
Milwaukee Brewers - Cecil Cooper
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente
Chicago Cubs - Ron Santo
St Louis Cardinals - Willie McGeeSan Francisco Giants - Barry Bonds
Los Angeles Dodgers - Fernando Valenzuela
San Diego Padres - Dave Winfield
Arizona Diamondbacks - Randy Johnson
Colorado Rockies - Vinny CastillaNew York Yankees - Derek Jeter
Boston Red Sox - Roger Clemens
Toronto Blue Jays - Dave Stieb
Baltimore Orioles - George Sisler
Tampa Bay Rays - Carl CrawfordCleveland - Albert Belle
Chicago White Sox - Wilbur Wood
Minnesota Twins - Kirby Puckett
Detroit Tigers - Lou Whitaker
Kansas City Royals - Willie WilsonSeattle Mariners - Ichiro Suzuki
Los Angeles Angels - Jim Fregosi
Texas Rangers - Rafael Palmeiro
Houston Astros - J.R. Richard
Oakland Athletics - Rube WaddellDefunct Organizations - Satchel Paige, Josh Gibson, Cool Papa Bell, Jack Glasscock, Old Hoss Radbourn
Did I forget your favorite player? Did I list someone already in the game? Am I a l[censored] moron? Leave your input below. Looking forward to your suggestions and comments.
J.R. Richard, one of the bigger what if's and it would be really cool to see SDS maybe do a couple guys a year to highlight some of them who would have been household names had there careers not been cut tragically short. I think baseball and its fans embrace the games history and former players in a way no oter sport does. I love talking to my son about many of the Legends and passing on the stories my father told me as a kid about guys like Gibson, Koufax, Mantle, Clemente etc.
Clemente and Richard would actually be a pretty good couple guys to start with. Nice list and Stieb was fealty he reallly had some crazy movement
Great response. Completely agree on Richard. I’ve been fascinated with his career since I was a kid, though he medically retired right before I was born, and I have no doubt he would be a hall of famer if not for his stroke (which I blame Astros doctors on, but that’s another story).
Some of the choices I made for the list weren’t necessarily because the player was the best on his team not in the game, but players I think should be remembered more. Guys like Dave Stieb, Jim Fregosi and Lou Whitaker. Dominant stars in their day, but hardly talked about anymore outside their respective fan bases.
-
for the mets id like to see RA Dickey and for the braves Phil Niekro
-
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Chicago Cubs - Ron Santo
BOOM. Do it SDS!
-
Cubs need Lee and Ramirez
-
@Potawatomi_Kid said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Cubs need Lee and Ramirez
Gabby Hartnett, specifically his 1930 season. We need more options at catcher.
-
@formallyforearms said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@Potawatomi_Kid said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Cubs need Lee and Ramirez
Gabby Hartnett, specifically his 1930 season. We need more options at catcher.
I would LOVE that card
-
@OreoRockstar said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Dodgers Steve Sax is all I could ever ask for....No one would use him but me, but it would be the dream.
I lie, for pitching I would love Pedro, Fernando, or Koufax.
I so would use Sax and or Davey Lopes
-
@wolfTex77 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Some of these players have been in previous versions of the game, some are virtually impossible due to rights issues, but here is a personal wish list of one player from each team I wish was in The Show.
Atlanta Braves - Hank Aaron
Washington Nationals - Tim Raines
Miami Marlins - Dontrelle Willis
Philadelphia Phillies - Steve Carlton
New York Mets - Dwight GoodenCincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson
Milwaukee Brewers - Cecil Cooper
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente
Chicago Cubs - Ron Santo
St Louis Cardinals - Willie McGeeSan Francisco Giants - Barry Bonds
Los Angeles Dodgers - Fernando Valenzuela
San Diego Padres - Dave Winfield
Arizona Diamondbacks - Randy Johnson
Colorado Rockies - Vinny CastillaNew York Yankees - Derek Jeter
Boston Red Sox - Roger Clemens
Toronto Blue Jays - Dave Stieb
Baltimore Orioles - George Sisler
Tampa Bay Rays - Carl CrawfordCleveland - Albert Belle
Chicago White Sox - Wilbur Wood
Minnesota Twins - Kirby Puckett
Detroit Tigers - Lou Whitaker
Kansas City Royals - Willie WilsonSeattle Mariners - Ichiro Suzuki
Los Angeles Angels - Jim Fregosi
Texas Rangers - Rafael Palmeiro
Houston Astros - J.R. Richard
Oakland Athletics - Rube WaddellDefunct Organizations - Satchel Paige, Josh Gibson, Cool Papa Bell, Jack Glasscock, Old Hoss Radbourn
Did I forget your favorite player? Did I list someone already in the game? Am I a l[censored] moron? Leave your input below. Looking forward to your suggestions and comments.
J.R. Richard, one of the bigger what if's and it would be really cool to see SDS maybe do a couple guys a year to highlight some of them who would have been household names had there careers not been cut tragically short. I think baseball and its fans embrace the games history and former players in a way no oter sport does. I love talking to my son about many of the Legends and passing on the stories my father told me as a kid about guys like Gibson, Koufax, Mantle, Clemente etc.
Clemente and Richard would actually be a pretty good couple guys to start with. Nice list and Stieb was fealty he reallly had some crazy movement
Thurman Munson
-
Here is my list
Atlanta Braves - Hank Aaron
Washington Nationals - Tim Raines
Miami Marlins - Jeff Conine
Philadelphia Phillies - Steve Carlton
New York Mets - Darryl StrawberryCincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson
Milwaukee Brewers - Cecil Cooper
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente
Chicago Cubs - Rick Sutcliffe
St Louis Cardinals - Terry PendletonSan Francisco Giants - Barry Bonds
Los Angeles Dodgers - Sandy Koufax
San Diego Padres - Dave Winfield
Arizona Diamondbacks - Randy Johnson
Colorado Rockies - Andres GalarragaNew York Yankees - Bernie Williams
Boston Red Sox - Carl Yastremski
Toronto Blue Jays - Roy Halladay
Baltimore Orioles - Mike Mussina
Tampa Bay Rays - Carl CrawfordCleveland - Tris Speaker
Chicago White Sox - Shoeless Joe Jackson (To bad he is band from baseball)
Minnesota Twins - Kent Hrbek
Detroit Tigers - Lou Whitaker
Kansas City Royals - Frank WhiteSeattle Mariners - Dave Henderson
Los Angeles Angels - Fred Lynn
Texas Rangers - Kenny Rogers
Houston Astros - Jose Cruz
Oakland Athletics - Al Simmons -
I will add the either card I would love is a Rangers Rusty Greer. He is a friend as my son has worked with him on defensive training for the last couple years....be a fun card for a kamikaze outfielder.
-
@formallyforearms said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@Potawatomi_Kid said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Cubs need Lee and Ramirez
Gabby Hartnett, specifically his 1930 season. We need more options at catcher.
Hartnett would be great. He would have to have the night owl (or whatever it’s called) perk.
-
@dbarmonstar said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@wolfTex77 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
@MarinerMatt01 said in One Player From Each Team I wish Was in the Game:
Some of these players have been in previous versions of the game, some are virtually impossible due to rights issues, but here is a personal wish list of one player from each team I wish was in The Show.
Atlanta Braves - Hank Aaron
Washington Nationals - Tim Raines
Miami Marlins - Dontrelle Willis
Philadelphia Phillies - Steve Carlton
New York Mets - Dwight GoodenCincinnati Reds - Frank Robinson
Milwaukee Brewers - Cecil Cooper
Pittsburgh Pirates - Roberto Clemente
Chicago Cubs - Ron Santo
St Louis Cardinals - Willie McGeeSan Francisco Giants - Barry Bonds
Los Angeles Dodgers - Fernando Valenzuela
San Diego Padres - Dave Winfield
Arizona Diamondbacks - Randy Johnson
Colorado Rockies - Vinny CastillaNew York Yankees - Derek Jeter
Boston Red Sox - Roger Clemens
Toronto Blue Jays - Dave Stieb
Baltimore Orioles - George Sisler
Tampa Bay Rays - Carl CrawfordCleveland - Albert Belle
Chicago White Sox - Wilbur Wood
Minnesota Twins - Kirby Puckett
Detroit Tigers - Lou Whitaker
Kansas City Royals - Willie WilsonSeattle Mariners - Ichiro Suzuki
Los Angeles Angels - Jim Fregosi
Texas Rangers - Rafael Palmeiro
Houston Astros - J.R. Richard
Oakland Athletics - Rube WaddellDefunct Organizations - Satchel Paige, Josh Gibson, Cool Papa Bell, Jack Glasscock, Old Hoss Radbourn
Did I forget your favorite player? Did I list someone already in the game? Am I a l[censored] moron? Leave your input below. Looking forward to your suggestions and comments.
J.R. Richard, one of the bigger what if's and it would be really cool to see SDS maybe do a couple guys a year to highlight some of them who would have been household names had there careers not been cut tragically short. I think baseball and its fans embrace the games history and former players in a way no oter sport does. I love talking to my son about many of the Legends and passing on the stories my father told me as a kid about guys like Gibson, Koufax, Mantle, Clemente etc.
Clemente and Richard would actually be a pretty good couple guys to start with. Nice list and Stieb was fealty he reallly had some crazy movement
Thurman Munson
Thurmon Munson isn’t a “what if,” he’s a “what was.” Already a Great when he tragically passed away. He should be in the Hall of Fame and he should be in this game.
