Best Players at Each Position?

[seunguk0317_PSN]

@raesONE said in Best Players at Each Position?:

@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:

*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>Jansen

Gehrig > Ruth
Trout > Mantle

Havent used Gehrig and Trout much, are they really better?

[raesONE_PSN]

@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:

@raesONE said in Best Players at Each Position?:

@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:

*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>Jansen

Gehrig > Ruth
Trout > Mantle

Havent used Gehrig and Trout much, are they really better?

They are in my opinion, yes. It's all about the swing.

[high-heat-27_PSN]

Most will say this
1B Ruth
2B Cap or Wagner
SS tatis
3B JRam or chipper
LF trout
CF mantle
RF walker
C FOXX or CAP

[Piikzl_PSN]

@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:

@raesONE said in Best Players at Each Position?:

@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:

*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>Jansen

Gehrig > Ruth
Trout > Mantle

Havent used Gehrig and Trout much, are they really better?

gehrig is basically just babe with a different swing, so it''s whichever you prefer, but obviously babe is much easier to get. and i personally think trout is the best player in the game

[DanTheThriller]

It seems like Gehrig vs. Ruth is the real debate.

[mwolve87_PSN]

How about Ted Williams vs. Larry Walker. Is it worth giving up some D for Ted's elite bat?

[ZFree1122_PSN]

@mwolve87 said in Best Players at Each Position?:

How about Ted Williams vs. Larry Walker. Is it worth giving up some D for Ted's elite bat?

I use Ted as my high leverage vs RHP bat and Prestige Walker as my low leverage (working on Cobb prestige). I would start Walker in right if I had Cobb done. Larry Walkers 99 Arm in right legit plays.

[Quint75_PSN]

C Foxx, Pudge, d’Arnaud
1B Ruth, Gehrig, Musial, Thomas, Foxx
2B Tatis Jr, Hornsby
SS Tatis Jr
3B Foxx, Tatis Jr, Chipper
OF Trout, Mantle, Williams, Ruth, Cobb, Musial, Brock, Walker
P Gibson, Hershiser, Maddux, Kluber, Sale, Seaver
BP Dibble, Wagner, Chapman, McGee, Fingers, Rivera, Crochet, Hoffman, Kimbrel

[Bob_Loblaw1984_PSN]

C : CAP, Posada, Will Smith, d'Arnaud, Grandal
1B: Gehrig, Ruth, Foxx, Pujols, Thomas, Thames
2B: Jackie, Biggio, Sandberg, Cano, Hornsby, Alomar
SS: Tatis, Wagner, Rollins, Correa, Turner, Mondesi
3B: J-Ram, Chipper, Brett, Donaldson, Matthews
OF: Trout, Mantle, Walker, Cobb, Harper, Snider, Robert, Williams, Brock, Dawson
SP: Kershaw, Maddux, Orel, Gibson, Seaver, Mize, Wood, Sale, Feller, Scherzer, Leiter, Blyleven
L BP: Wagner, Chapman, Crochet, Britton, Franco, McGee
R BP: Goose, Mo, Kenley, Rollie, Davis, Gagne, Dibble

[lazy_toast_PSN]

@Quint75 said in Best Players at Each Position?:

C Foxx, Pudge, d’Arnaud
1B Ruth, Gehrig, Musial, Thomas, Foxx
2B Tatis Jr, Hornsby
SS Tatis Jr
3B Foxx, Tatis Jr, Chipper
OF Trout, Mantle, Williams, Ruth, Cobb, Musial, Brock, Walker
P Gibson, Hershiser, Maddux, Kluber, Sale
BP Dibble, Wagner, Chapman, McGee, Fingers, Rivera, Crochet, Hoffman, Kimbrel

Not a bad list. But with Kimbrel in there I just can’t take you seriously lol. JK. But seriously no Kimbrel