Cobb or Kershaw

My OF is currently WalkerRF, MantleCF, RuthLF - have CAP at 1st who is my best hitter by far which is why Ruth is in the OF. Also have 99Thames and castellano on bench for backup OF

Pitching staff is:
Seaver
Schmoltz
Prestige Paxton
Kluber
Hal

Who should I take?

Easily replace smoltz with Kershaw

Cobb is the best of the 3 bosses. Naturally I'd say take him, move Ruth to 1B because 60 speed in the OF hurt me the few games I played him out there before I moved him to 1B. Cobb smashes everything, a gapper is an automatic 3B, and he runs down everything in the OF. That being said, if your cap is your best hitter and you dont want to bench him, take Kershaw. I have all 3 bosses, they are all great for me, but Cobb is the best of the bunch. Kershaw isnt nearly as bad as some reviews suggest, though, just gotta know how to pitch with him and mix your pitches.

thanks for the help here, have had pack sitting in inbox since last night going back and forth between the two.

@Nanos_McGregor said in Cobb or Kershaw:

Easily replace smoltz with Kershaw

I'm extremely close to prestige him

Move your CAP off first, bruh. He will still be your best hitter at C, SS, or 2nd.

@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Cobb or Kershaw:

Move your CAP off first, bruh. He will still be your best hitter at C, SS, or 2nd.

I only have 1 and he's 1b - don't have the time to grind out another one as well as go after all of the new content constantly coming out.

Your team needs Kershaw more than it needs Cobb.

@Jeviduty said in Cobb or Kershaw:

Your team needs Kershaw more than it needs Cobb.

just took Kershaw thanks again for everyone's help

@njslugger25 said in Cobb or Kershaw:

@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Cobb or Kershaw:

Move your CAP off first, bruh. He will still be your best hitter at C, SS, or 2nd.

I only have 1 and he's 1b - don't have the time to grind out another one as well as go after all of the new content constantly coming out.

It doesn’t take much time. All you need to do are some easy moments and then plug in your lineup.

Pick Cobb he is a five tool player besides arm strength and put a Ruth on the bench or at first if u feel u need him in the lineup