Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?

SDS

Don't post here often but could really use some advice on what will most likely be my last big purchase of the year. This is my current roster:

1-Honus
2-Chipper/Bregman
3-Ruth
4-Pujols/Gehrig
5-Bellinger
6-Bench
7-Griffey Jr./Mays
8-Alomar

Bench: Yelich and Ichiro

SP: Kershaw, Feller, Seaver, Kluber, and Paxton

RP/CP: Corbin, Fingers, Hoffman, Yates, Hader, Jansen, and Wagner

I'm also planning to replace Yates with Romo and might also replace Hoffman with Eckersley. Unfortunately Extreme Moments cards are not an option for me because I lack the patience to even attempt them. After seeing my roster who do you guys think would be the best addition to my team out of Foxx, Sale, and Gagne?

SDS

I love all of them, but with the new game coming out soon, I don't think it makes sense to buy Sale when it could be a week before he takes the mound.
Gagne is my favorite reliever and Jimmie is my favorite hitter, so that's a tough choice between the two, I'd probably go Foxx, see if you like the sweet swing heading into 20.

SDS

@eatyum said in Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?:

I love all of them, but with the new game coming out soon, I don't think it makes sense to buy Sale when it could be a week before he takes the mound.
Gagne is my favorite reliever and Jimmie is my favorite hitter, so that's a tough choice between the two, I'd probably go Foxx, see if you like the sweet swing heading into 20.

Yeah you're probably right about it being a waste buying Sale since I'll probably only get to actually use him less than a handful of times before 20 comes out.

Foxx is tough because I know he's a great card but I already dominate with Pujols so it might actually be a bad idea for me to replace him. On the other hand if he hits similar to Babe and can face both righties and lefties I seriously may consider him since I could replace both Pujols and Gehrig with a single card.

Gagne is the card I'm leaning towards the most right now since my bullpen is still somewhat shaky.

SDS

@Ultimate_E_003 said in Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?:

@eatyum said in Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?:

I love all of them, but with the new game coming out soon, I don't think it makes sense to buy Sale when it could be a week before he takes the mound.
Gagne is my favorite reliever and Jimmie is my favorite hitter, so that's a tough choice between the two, I'd probably go Foxx, see if you like the sweet swing heading into 20.

Yeah you're probably right about it being a waste buying Sale since I'll probably only get to actually use him less than a handful of times before 20 comes out.

Foxx is tough because I know he's a great card but I already dominate with Pujols so it might actually be a bad idea for me to replace him. On the other hand if he hits similar to Babe and can face both righties and lefties I seriously may consider him since I could replace both Pujols and Gehrig with a single card.

Gagne is the card I'm leaning towards the most right now since my bullpen is still somewhat shaky.

You can't go wrong either way, I use Gagne heavily, especially in events.
In 182.1 innings Gagne has a 3.01 ERA, 0.90 WHIP, 34-7 with 22 saves in 25 attempts and 28 holds.

Foxx has 579 at-bats, .366/.419/.653 statline, I actually like using him vs righties better, .381 average vs righties .316 vs lefties. He and Babe Ruth are the only batters I have over 1.000 OPS

SDS

I'd go Foxx because you'd get more use out of him than Gagne and he's really good

SDS

@eatyum said in Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?:

@Ultimate_E_003 said in Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?:

@eatyum said in Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?:

I love all of them, but with the new game coming out soon, I don't think it makes sense to buy Sale when it could be a week before he takes the mound.
Gagne is my favorite reliever and Jimmie is my favorite hitter, so that's a tough choice between the two, I'd probably go Foxx, see if you like the sweet swing heading into 20.

Yeah you're probably right about it being a waste buying Sale since I'll probably only get to actually use him less than a handful of times before 20 comes out.

Foxx is tough because I know he's a great card but I already dominate with Pujols so it might actually be a bad idea for me to replace him. On the other hand if he hits similar to Babe and can face both righties and lefties I seriously may consider him since I could replace both Pujols and Gehrig with a single card.

Gagne is the card I'm leaning towards the most right now since my bullpen is still somewhat shaky.

You can't go wrong either way, I use Gagne heavily, especially in events.
In 182.1 innings Gagne has a 3.01 ERA, 0.90 WHIP, 34-7 with 22 saves in 25 attempts and 28 holds.

Foxx has 579 at-bats, .366/.419/.653 statline, I actually like using him vs righties better, .381 average vs righties .316 vs lefties. He and Babe Ruth are the only batters I have over 1.000 OPS

This was the post that I needed to see! Was really only thinking about RS earlier but with Events I definitely see the benefit of having Gagne in the bullpen since I can use him regularly. Lol can't wait to roll out the 3 headed monster of Jansen, Wagner, and Gagne now!

SDS

@JustASeal0 said in Foxx, Sale, or Gagne?:

I'd go Foxx because you'd get more use out of him than Gagne and he's really good

Think I'm gonna go with Gagne for now but if I decide to grind and build up some stubs again I'll definitely give Foxx a try.