All defensive

SDS

If you guys had to make a lineup out of the best defenders at each position at this point in DD, who would go where?

SDS

Frank Thomas at 1B for sure πŸ˜‚

SDS

@mitchhammond24 said in All defensive:

Frank Thomas at 1B for sure πŸ˜‚

He’s even better at 3B

SDS

C - Bench
1B - Hernandez or Bellinger
2B - Morgan
SS - Smith or Wagner
3B - Robinson or Arenado
RF - Ichiro
CF - Mays
LF - Henderson

The second pick is not a good but only slightly worse but so much better offensively

SDS

C Kendall
1b Pujols
2b Mazeroski
SS Visquel
3b Robinson
LF Gordon
CF Cobb/Griffey to close for me Cobb range Jr. Arm both amazing
Rf Ichiro

Tried almost every player at one time or another but never did the collections for May's or Wagner I'm sure there awesome to use. Also I would change a few out if I was making a lineup using secondary positions but those were the guys I thought were the best

SDS

C - Yadi
1B - Keith
2B - Mazeroski
3B - Chapman
SS - Simba
LF - Alex Gordon
CF - Mays
RF - Ichiro
P - Greinke

SDS

P Grienke

Almost forgot

SDS

Of the ones I've used...

C - Bench or Pudge
1B - Adrian Gonzalez
2B - Cano
SS - Wagner
3B - Brooks Robinson
LF - Henderson
CF - Mays
RF - Gwynn/Ichiro
P - Grienke

If using secondary positions
C - Bench/Pudge
1B - Bellinger
2B - Cano
SS - Wagner
3B - Brooks Robinson
LF - Griffey
CF - Mays
RF - Gwynn/Ichiro

SDS

The All D team:
C Pudge
1st A-Gon
2nd Alomar
3rd Chapman
SS Honus
CF Mays
RF Ichiro
LF Gwynn

The team I use:

C Pudge
1st Bellinger (over A-Gon because of his bat, speed and ability to put Belli in the OF late game)
2nd Alomar
3rd Arenado over Chapman (because of his bat)
SS Honus
CF Mays
RF Griffey (over Ichiro because of his bat)
LF Williams (even though he's a defensive liability)

I keep Ichiro and Gwynn on the bench, as well as Frank Thomas which frees up Bellenger and essentially gives me 3 options to replace Williams in left. Aside from Williams, all those players play fantastic defence, and while a couple of them aren't quite the best options defensively, their offensive abilities are far superior to any other option. At least in my eyes.