Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players

[Breadsticks21221]

@samguenther1987 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

Fingers
Hershiser
Ruth

Posada
Foster
Kluber (I honestly have no idea who this could be though)

Worse this time. (I'm gonna give everyone a brief hint on their guess starting now)

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@Breadsticks21221 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

@samguenther1987 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

Fingers
Hershiser
Ruth

Posada
Foster
Kluber (I honestly have no idea who this could be though)

Worse this time. (I'm gonna give everyone a brief hint on their guess starting now)

How did he do on the first three?

[the_dragon1912_PSN]

Big head is probably Mile Scott not Foster

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@the_dragon1912 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

Big head is probably Mile Scott not Foster

I have no clue for the last two. Lol

[Breadsticks21221]

I’ll give hints about the players tomorrow

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@Breadsticks21221 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

I’ll give hints about the players tomorrow

Thank you good sir. I will guess in a bit. Need to ponder.

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

Whelp, I forgot yesterday. I am again going to wait for @Breadsticks21221 to get on for a hint. Lol

[Breadsticks21221]

Hint today: Beach doesn't relate to the beach ball pack. @jz2016cubs @samguenther1987 @IIJACKINTHBOXII @nflman2033 @the_dragon1912

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@Breadsticks21221 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

Hint today: Beach doesn't relate to the beach ball pack. @jz2016cubs @samguenther1987 @IIJACKINTHBOXII @nflman2033 @the_dragon1912

Ohhh. I still have NO clue. Lol

[samguenther1987_PSN]

Fingers
Hershiser
Ruth

Machado
Foster
Christy Mathewson

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@samguenther1987 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

Fingers
Hershiser
Ruth

Machado
Foster
Christy Mathewson

Oooh. I like those guesses

[the_dragon1912_PSN]

Fingers
Hershiser
Mantle

Machado
Mike Scott
Babe(the house that babe built)

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@Breadsticks21221
Fingers
Hershiser
Jason Giambi

Machado
gonna go with @samguenther1987 FOSTER!
Babe

[Breadsticks21221]

You guys aren’t even close on my least favorite. Favorites well...someone got them all and of you have 2. Another guess at 12 PT

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@Breadsticks21221 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

You guys aren’t even close on my least favorite. Favorites well...someone got them all and of you have 2. Another guess at 12 PT

WHO GOT THEM ALL!!?? Will there be a new hint then?

[Breadsticks21221]

@jz2016cubs said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

@Breadsticks21221 said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

You guys aren’t even close on my least favorite. Favorites well...someone got them all and of you have 2. Another guess at 12 PT

WHO GOT THEM ALL!!?? Will there be a new hint then?

I can’t say who got them all. New hint will be up in just a moment

[Breadsticks21221]

1 Mustache
2 Clutch pitcher
3 Bench bat

1 Team doesn’t play next to the ocean
2 Diamond defense
3 Can pitch forever

[IIJACKINTHBOXII]

1 Rollie Fingers
2 Orel Hershiser
3 Jason Giambi

1 Dante Bichette
2 Manny Machado
3 Hal Newhouser

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

@IIJACKINTHBOXII said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

1 Rollie Fingers
2 Orel Hershiser
3 Jason Giambi

1 Dante Bichette
2 Manny Machado
3 Hal Newhouser

I think you are right. Those were my guesses

[Breadsticks21221]

@IIJACKINTHBOXII said in Guess my most and least favorite MLB The Show players:

1 Rollie Fingers
2 Orel Hershiser
3 Jason Giambi

1 Dante Bichette
2 Manny Machado
3 Hal Newhouser

Close, missing 2