Feedback please

SDS

Current lineup:
LF Lou Brock L
SS Jimmy Rollins S
CF Larry Walker L
1B Stan Musial L
3B Rogers Hornsby R
2B Ryne Sandberg R
RF Giancarlo Stanton (HRD) R
C Joe Torre R
Pitcher

Just curious as to whether anybody thinks this lineup has a chance? Definitely has pop. Plan to replace Stanton with Ruth when I finish up this program.

SDS

Larry in CF would scare me a bit. You want your fastest guy in CF, but Brock wouldn't get it done. I'd look into getting that 98 Pache, or even the FOTF Buxton.

SDS

@lucas8181 said in Feedback please:

Larry in CF would scare me a bit. You want your fastest guy in CF, but Brock wouldn't get it done. I'd look into getting that 98 Pache, or even the FOTF Buxton.

Yeah Brock doesn’t get the jump on plays in center. Larry is ok out there but def just my bat right now.

SDS

@Croz_17 said in Feedback please:

@lucas8181 said in Feedback please:

Larry in CF would scare me a bit. You want your fastest guy in CF, but Brock wouldn't get it done. I'd look into getting that 98 Pache, or even the FOTF Buxton.

Yeah Brock doesn’t get the jump on plays in center. Larry is ok out there but def just my bat right now.

Pache has been a beast for me at the plate too. Unless you're hitting .500 or are keeping Stanton for the Trout collection, I'd consider selling him and getting a true CF. Move Walker to RF, and you're team is set. Obviously the IF is good to go.

SDS

I collected Stanton like an idiot...otherwise I would do that. I’m going to give Hornsby a try and if I can’t get anything outta him I’m gonna look to go the center fielder route

SDS

@Croz_17 said in Feedback please:

I collected Stanton like an idiot...otherwise I would do that. I’m going to give Hornsby a try and if I can’t get anything outta him I’m gonna look to go the center fielder route

oh, Get Robert then. Similar price, Robert is far superior. I took Hornsby out of the pack and wasn't impressed. Sold him and haven't looked back.

SDS

@lucas8181 said in Feedback please:

@Croz_17 said in Feedback please:

I collected Stanton like an idiot...otherwise I would do that. I’m going to give Hornsby a try and if I can’t get anything outta him I’m gonna look to go the center fielder route

oh, Get Robert then. Similar price, Robert is far superior. I took Hornsby out of the pack and wasn't impressed. Sold him and haven't looked back.

Doing that will give me speed galore. I’d throw Jackie back in the lineup in place of Hornsby and have Brock, Rollins, and Robert in the 90s speed plus sandberg at 80...speed kills lol

SDS

@Croz_17 said in Feedback please:

@lucas8181 said in Feedback please:

@Croz_17 said in Feedback please:

I collected Stanton like an idiot...otherwise I would do that. I’m going to give Hornsby a try and if I can’t get anything outta him I’m gonna look to go the center fielder route

oh, Get Robert then. Similar price, Robert is far superior. I took Hornsby out of the pack and wasn't impressed. Sold him and haven't looked back.

Doing that will give me speed galore. I’d throw Jackie back in the lineup in place of Hornsby and have Brock, Rollins, and Robert in the 90s speed plus sandberg at 80...speed kills lol

I don't think you'll be disappointed with that decision!