Optimal lineup

SDS

I’m trying to figure out an optimal lineup. Ive played some innings with some different lineups but cant figure out who I like best where.

1b: Killebrew/ Hornsby
2b: Hornsby/ POTM Correa
ss: POTM DIDI/ Correa
3b: Chipper
C- Sig Posada/ Posey
Of: POTM Bellinger, Ellsbury, FOTF Davis, Walker

Outfield is the big conundrum right now but infield isn’t far behind.

SDS

This is how I would do it:

CF: Davis
RF: Walker
3B: Chipper
2B: Hornsby
LF: Bellinger
1B: Killebrew
C : Posada
SS: Didi

SDS

C- biggio
1b- stan
2b- hornsby
SS- rollins
3b- sheffield
Rf- walker
Cf- trout
Lf- mantle

SDS

@xxJeffG101xx said in Optimal lineup:

C- biggio
1b- stan
2b- hornsby
SS- rollins
3b- sheffield
Rf- walker
Cf- trout
Lf- mantle

While I’d love to get there it will never happen. I work and travel too much to play that much.

SDS

Why is everyone picking Hornsby over Sig Jackie?

I realize he is a much better hitter; but I would think defense and speed would be better.

Plus take Sheff out of the OF and replace him with LOTF Brock.

Brock and Rollins in the 1-2 spot.

SDS

@AGENTSxOFxCHAOS said in Optimal lineup:

Why is everyone picking Hornsby over Sig Jackie?

I realize he is a much better hitter; but I would think defense and speed would be better.

Plus take Sheff out of the OF and replace him with LOTF Brock.

Brock and Rollins in the 1-2 spot.

Jackie is the best 2B available imo

SDS

I do like some Sandberg! Larry Walker plays for me in the OF with Mickey and one of Trout, Davis, Bellinger has a great swing, Musial too

SDS

@AGENTSxOFxCHAOS said in Optimal lineup:

Why is everyone picking Hornsby over Sig Jackie?

I realize he is a much better hitter; but I would think defense and speed would be better.

Plus take Sheff out of the OF and replace him with LOTF Brock.

Brock and Rollins in the 1-2 spot.

Because Jackie is the warning track God. 70 speed and silver fielding at 2B is not as good as Jackie or Sandberg or even Cano, but it's not awful either.