Your browser does not seem to support JavaScript. As a result, your viewing experience will be diminished, and you have been placed in read-only mode.
Please download a browser that supports JavaScript, or enable it if it's disabled (i.e. NoScript).
It’s been asked before but who do I take thinking Stan or Rollins. How have both been playing.
Also been wondering about this. Will be at 300 stars once I do the player program on Tuesday. Leaning towards Stan, but SS is a position of need for me.
Leading up to it, I was mainly thinking Maddux or Musial. Read a couple negative things about Maddux, and had enough good options at 1B so I went Rollins. I have not regretted it. About .350 with 10 XBH in about 50 ABs. Great defense too. If you plan on getting prestige on whoever you choose, I think Prestige Rollins will be best pick.
"Read a couple negative things about Maddux" is ridiculous. Most likely you're taking advice from someone who used him wrong or has never used him. Heck, content creators on youtube used him for 5 innings, sold him, then gave an opinion. He's a fantastic card, top 5 pitcher, end game.
All 3 are great, and yes, I have all three. Take who fits your team best, you can't make a bad choice.
Pick whoever is most expensive and sell. None of these guys are worth it in my humble opinion, but if you want to keep one of them that badly I would pick Stan Musial and play him either at 1B or on the bench as a PH.