@ChArTeRBuS said in Honus should have been this year’s Honus:
I think it’s really hard for SDS to balance ONE single card being the marquee guy. This forum was really adamant that some names (much much older players) are bigger names than guys that played in the 90s. Go on to twitch/youtube where the age demographic is different and you’ll hear something completely opposite from just as many people if not MORE.
Trout is about as close as you can get to pleasing the new school and old school fan base. Everybody respects Trout. I really don’t know what people were expecting or why everyone is so furious. He is one of the best players of all time. Period. Name any name, he isn’t Mike Trout, and he isn’t even close.
No doubt Trout is a fan favorite and we all love him both as a player and in the game. But a lot of us already have a 95 Trout (that’ll probably hit 96 most days with IE). So instead of getting a shiny new toy, we get a slightly shinier version of a toy we already grinded to get. Last year, we had no Honus Wagner, so a 99 Honus was a completely new card.