Biggio, Posey , Weiter ....
-
Only people who have tried all 3 respond please.
Which one do you use when owning all 3 ?
Pros? Cons? And why one over the other.
Weiter the best defender.
Biggio speed
Posey against left handedSoooo, what do you value more?
-
The correct answer is Pablo Sandoval
-
Wieters if you don't play above all star. Biggio if you feel guilty with all the stubs locked in and dont play him at 2B or LF. I prefer posey. He doesnt allow any passed balls and he demolishes lefty pitching and is a singles machine vs righties. Weiters has a great swing but his pci can be small on hof and legend. Depends on your skill and who's swing you like better. I had biggio since about a month into the game and he is solid but now a bench bat/runner. Seems like he has noodle bat games then goes on a hitting streak . Very streaky hitter for me, not consistent enough like weiters or posey. Overall i like posey best.
-
Posey for general games.
Weiters works well against speed-focused teams and you need the extra arm strength. I keep him on the bench just in case the opponent likes to run.
As T-Rox mentioned, Weiters hitting is mediocre so Posey is the general go-to pick.
Biggio's biggest issues are his hitting and opponents can run circles around the bases on him if they have 90+speed.
Biggio can be used as a pinch runner for both and then be slotted into catcher later on if you need the extra speed in late inning situations.
-
Joe Torre is another option that nobody talks about. I hit much better with him compared to biggio and Posey.
-
I played Biggio at 2nd and tried Wieters for a week or so. I prefer Posey.
Blocking is uncanny and shouldn’t be undervalued.
Hitting vs. righties is good if you use him correctly (go the other way vs. RHP). Versus lefties he’s a monster and does a nice job protecting lefty batters.
Vision is adequate for HOF.
Arm is good enough.
-
Biggio is endgame C for me. The guy is so well rounded across the board. And even if you can’t hit w him you can bunt cheese With him even though it’s stupid. Plus the 90 speed. Who else could do that at catcher
-
Have had all three and loved Biggio easily the best of the three. I use Posey off the bench at first for lefties. Wieters was terrible for me and I love switch hitters.
-
@T-Rox_09 said in Biggio, Posey , Weiter ....:
Wieters if you don't play above all star. Biggio if you feel guilty with all the stubs locked in and dont play him at 2B or LF. I prefer posey. He doesnt allow any passed balls and he demolishes lefty pitching and is a singles machine vs righties. Weiters has a great swing but his pci can be small on hof and legend. Depends on your skill and who's swing you like better. I had biggio since about a month into the game and he is solid but now a bench bat/runner. Seems like he has noodle bat games then goes on a hitting streak . Very streaky hitter for me, not consistent enough like weiters or posey. Overall i like posey best.
LOL biggio if you feel guilty locking in stubs! That's funny, sad, and true.. I think it was having 90 speed at c.. Strange I see YouTubers and some opponents hit so well with him... I'm hitting 256 with him around 26 hrs... Your assessment of posey is on point... Except I don't hit that much r VS r.. Long term I see him on thr bench in situations... I couldn't hit well with panda... I'm thinking of starting a cap..
-
Order: Posey, Biggio, Wieters. Wieters has too low contact against righty’s. I like Posey and Biggio so I play Biggio at 2nd and Posey behind the plate
-
I always end up back with biggio. Stubb obligation and the time it took to turn him red
-
None. Somehow Kendall works for me this year
-
A admin locked this topic on
