I've had plenty of instances where my opponent squares up perfect after perfect. Everything is always very well hit like he can't miss... almost like he knows where I'm spotting the ball before I even pitch the ball. That made me think of going into my settings and turning off the pitching ball marker in the middle of the game. For some reason, from that point on my opponent flails and pops everything up as if he is trying to guess where and what I'm going to throw.
Is there some sort of MLB The Show aim bot that I'm not aware of? This is too much of a coincidence for me to believe. I'm happy to have a screen share to show what I'm talking about.