Over the years, I could have a league-leading starting pitcher who leads the league in voting, goes on to win cy young. Why is it that I’ve never had one of them make the all star roster? Is this a game glitch? What am I doing wrong?
Check their mid-season stats. They could just have breakout years. Also, check how many teams have their sole representatives as SPs. Those could be taking up spots.
I have had this issue since I can’t remember how long. Perhaps they cap it if you have position players as well. I’ve had relievers make the team, just never a starter.