Controller issue in Quick Manage mode in Franchise

[Dave Kellogg_XBL]

When I'm in Franchise mode and go into "Play Next Game" and select Quick Manage, my controllers are mixed up. I have just one XBox controller and it has always been P1. The screen shows P1 and P2 in the middle between the two team logos. Usually, I can move P1 over to my team and press the A button to go to the next screen. However, it is only letting me move the P2 over but when I do that, I am only controlling the other team and it won't let me manage my team. I have tried restarting the XBox and resetting the controller to no avail.