Mauer or Comet?
- 
I know I know, it’s up to me…depends on my roster. 
 I just pulled Mauer out of a 50pk and wondering if I should sell for Cosmic Comet. I’m mostly offline (95/5) and a Yankee fan but wondering stat wise and also wild card-wise, if I should sell. Thanks in advance.
- 
Mauer has a significantly better swing. 
- 
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Mauer or Comet?: Mauer has a significantly better swing. Really? I love Mickey Mantle and his defense is A1. Maurer looks good as well but I don’t think his more valuable than Mickey plus Mickey is a switch hitter 
- 
Lots of good OF cards while not very many high end Cs IMO. I pulled Mantle from a free equipment collection pack and sold RedTurn2 and a few Core cards to buy Mauer. 
- 
@OlSkoolE63_PSN said in Mauer or Comet?: I know I know, it’s up to me…depends on my roster. 
 I just pulled Mauer out of a 50pk and wondering if I should sell for Cosmic Comet. I’m mostly offline (95/5) and a Yankee fan but wondering stat wise and also wild card-wise, if I should sell. Thanks in advance.Mantle is the better card of the two…However there are no other elite Season 2 catchers right now & there are always plenty of outfielders. But in all honesty - Since you’re an offline player it really doesn’t matter. You’ll be fine with either player. 
- 
@H-TOWN713-X1HQX_XBL said in Mauer or Comet?: @Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Mauer or Comet?: Mauer has a significantly better swing. Really? I love Mickey Mantle and his defense is A1. Maurer looks good as well but I don’t think his more valuable than Mickey plus Mickey is a switch hitter I also love Mickey and agree his defense excellent. Unfortunately those two things do not affect his terrible swing. If you’re good with it, more power to ya. 
- 
that Mauer card is juiced out of its mind and catchers are few and far between so I would keep Mauer. I love Mantle too but there is always 7-9 outfielders I could plug in at any given time and get the same production 
- 
Mantle is a beast offense and defense 
- 
Thanks folks for all the input. I guess I’ll keep him and find a way to buy Mantle. I’m not much of a market mogul so I’ll have to figure something out but I’ll get it done. 
- 
A admin locked this topic on





